We are building an alternative social media site so you can read various points of view outside of the usual echo-chambers and submit your civil comments without fear of trolling or being flooded with suggestions to join extremist “news” outlets and organizations from the left or right. 

Unlike the Big Social Media sites, we do not hide behind Section 230, the law that protects such sites from libelous posts submitted by their readers. The Hustings is on Thanksgiving recess until December 1, but we will still be looking for your comments to post in the left or right column. 

Please send your comments on our debates and News & Notes to editors@thehustings.news and tell us whether you consider yourself “left” or “right.”

Email us your comments on …

•The $1.75 trillion Build Back Better social infrastructure bill, HR 5376, passed by the House of Representatives just before the chamber took its Thanksgiving week recess. The bill now proceeds to the Senate, which could vote on it as early as December, but more likely January. Any Senate amendments will send the bill back to the House before it can be sent to the Oval Office for President Biden’s signature. 

Our flash debate on the question of whether the January 6 Capitol insurrection was “dress rehearsal” for the 2024 presidential election.

Observations by Stephen Macaulay and Bryan Williams on Republican Glenn Youngkin’s Virginia gubernatorial election victory.

Keep scrolling and you eventually will find our first home-page debates, covering the Fall 2020 presidential debates between Joe Biden and then-President Trump.

_____________________________________

Your Arguments for BBB Here

The House of Representatives has passed the $1.75-trillion Build Back Better social infrastructure bill, HR 5376. The bill now proceeds to the Senate, which could vote on it as early as December, but more likely January. Any Senate amendments will send the bill back to the House before it goes to the Oval Office for President Biden’s signature. 

What do you think of the bill? Will it fuel or slow inflation? Will it reverse 40 years of Reaganomics? Help continue the conversation and send your comments to editors@thehustings.news. Please keep it civil and tell us whether you are left or right. 

Join our effort to provide an alternative to Big Social Media.

Scroll down to read, and comment on more:

•Stephen Macaulay’s right-column commentary on Trump administration Chief of Staff Mark Meadows’ claim of executive privilege in his attempt to avoid testifying before the January 6 House select committee.

The Hustings debate, “Was January 6 a ‘Dress Rehearsal’?” with news and analysis on the issue in the middle column, and commentary in the left and right columns.

Observations by Stephen Macaulay and Bryan Williams on Republican Glenn Youngkin’s Virginia gubernatorial election victory.

_____

Daily News & Notes returns Wednesday, December 1. Send your comments on news and politics, and on our three-column debates to editors@thehustings.news.

FRI 11/19/21

The Hustings joins the Senate and House of Representatives in taking Thanksgiving recess. The Senate returns Monday, November 29, the House returns Tuesday, November 30 and The Hustings returns Wednesday, December 1. Happy Thanksgiving.

Build Back Better Passes House, 220-213 – Since when does the House filibuster? They call it the “Magic Minute” and House leaders may use it to speak for as long as they want. Then-Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, D-CA, used it to delay a vote on a Trump administration immigration bill in 2018. 

Current Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy’s, R-CA, Magic Minute came to eight hours, 32 minutes, by the time he finished at 4:46 a.m. EST Friday, The Hill reports, on his getting a COVID-19 booster, inflation, the Gettysburg Address, Tesla CEO Elon Musk, President Washington crossing the Delaware, and U.S. policy toward China. 

This was McCarthy’s Magic Minute to try and delay President Biden’s $1.75-trillion Build Back Better social infrastructure bill. On that, the minority leader said this: “You are spending so much money. Never before!”

McCarthy’s warning on the level of spending surely will echo on the Senate floor when that chamber takes up the bill next month, or more likely, next year. 

Keep in mind the $1.75-trillion BBB covers 10 years of spending. Yesterday, the Congressional Budget Office turned in its report scoring the BBB, with the estimate it will add $367 billion to the federal budget deficit over those next 10 years. HR 3576’s Democratic proponents argue the CBO score does not count an additional $207 billion in revenue it has estimated the BBB would bring in by providing more money for IRS enforcement, according to The Hill’s report.

The math v. McCarthy:

BBB deficit spending minus the estimated increase in tax revenues from the added IRS enforcement comes to $160 billion over 10 years, or an average of $16 billion per year, per the CBO report.

The CBO projected the contentious Trump administration’s 2017 Tax Cut and Jobs Act would add $1.9 trillion to the deficit over 10 years, which averages out to $190 billion per year.

Senators have proposed nearly 1,000 amendments to the annual National Defense Authorization Act, which reached the Senate floor Thursday (Politico). One of these is by Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-VT, a lead proponent of BBB, who wants to slash 10% from military spending. The White House has requested $715 billion – that’s for 2022 – but the Senate Armed Services Committee has requested $740 billion, or $25 billion more. For one year. 

Republicans can legitimately protest a big social safety net spending bill coming during the pandemic and 6.2% annual inflation. They cannot legitimately claim it is anywhere near the biggest spending bill, ever.

The House passed HR 5376 just before 10 a.m. Friday, by 220-213 vote. Rep. Jared Golden, D-ME, was the only congress member to vote against his party on the bill, which now proceeds to the Senate.

“This bill is monumental,” Speaker Pelosi said in a press conference after the vote. “It’s historic, it’s bigger than anything we’ve ever done.”

•••

Navarro Subpoenaed by House COVID Committee -- Peter Navarro, failed politician (he ran for office in San Diego five times and secured victory zero times) and economist of dubious repute (he is a big proponent of tariffs, which even Adam Smith knew didn’t work out well for those on the receiving end), the man who served in the Trump administration as director of the Office of Trade and Manufacturing Policy (a position created for him that ceased to exist post-Trump presidency, which gives you an indication of its value: Do created positions in government ever go away unless they are completely dubious?), has been issued a subpoena by the House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Crisis, according to Politico.

Note: When Politico contacted Navarro regarding the congressional investigation, he responded, “I will be delivering a case of my new book In Trump Time to members of the committee which explains why this is indeed a witch hunt.”

What do we see here?

The completely mercenary approach of people who were in the Trump administration (“my new book”). One of Navarro’s roles was to secure medical supplies and drugs. Apparently, there were contracts let to companies without open bidding to, Politico reports, “companies with close ties to the administration.” Remember the lack of personal protective equipment (PPE)? That was in Navarro’s remit. 

The continued nonsensical claims (“witch hunt”). Navarro, when leading efforts to respond to the pandemic, a man with no background in science, no background in medicine, pushed hydroxychloroquine. Even though the FDA had revoked emergency use authorization for the drug, Navarro still promoted it.

All the best people.

•••

Keep Your Kids Away from the Computer Screen for This – In the scrum following QAnon shaman Jacob Chansley’s sentencing to 41 months in federal prison for obstructing an official proceeding by participating in the January 6 Capitol insurrection, one reporter asked the defendant’s attorney what he considered “appropriate accountability” for ex-President Trump Mediaite reports.

“If you’re asking my opinion, my opinion is meaningless,” Chansley’s attorney, Albert Watkins, replied. “I will say that I would probably be far more effective over a beer with former President Trump, even if he didn’t have a beer, because I understand he doesn’t drink beer, but I’d have a beer. And I’d tell him, ‘you know what? You’ve got a few fucking things to do. Including clearing this fucking mess up and taking care of a lot of the jackasses that you fucked up because of January 6.” (Note that Chansley pleaded guilty to his charges.) Watkins continued, “In the meantime, I might talk to him about some other things that I agree with him on. But my opinion doesn’t mean shit.”

--Edited by Todd Lassa and Gary S. Vasilash

____________________________________

THU 11/18/21

President Biden will host the first “Three Amigos” summit since 2016 at the White House today, with Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and Mexican President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador.

Biden has called on the Federal Trade Commission to investigate whether retail gas and natural gas prices are being manipulated by Big Oil. ‘Unfinished’ gas costs are decreasing while gasoline prices at the pump are up 60% from a year ago (Marketplace).

Not political, thankfully, but worth noting: The longest partial lunar eclipse in 580 years may be viewed anywhere in North America, beginning 1:02 a.m. EST Friday/10:02 PST tonight and runs three hours, 28 minutes and 24 seconds.

House Censures Gosar – That Rep. Paul Gosar, R-AZ, was censured by the House of Representatives 223 for and 207 against (with one being “present”) should come as no surprise. As there were only two Republican members — Liz Cheney of Wyoming and Adam Kinzinger of Illinois — who joined the Democrats in punishing Gosar for posting a video showing an anime video of him killing Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, of New York, and threatening the president is also not surprising.

What is surprising is how the GOP — once the party that was arguably the “grown-up” party, standing for things like morality and responsibility -- has become the Party Without Shame.

Here’s a simple metric: remember the book that came out some years ago titled All I Really Need to Know I Learned in Kindergarten? Let’s apply author Robert Fulghum’s metric to the behavior of the Republicans in this instance.

First, there is Gosar. Unrepentant for that video. Is this behavior that should be supported in children: “Here’s a picture of me killing Johnny: Whaddaya think, Mom?”

There is the claim that his staff posted it and he didn’t. Where is the taking of responsibility? “I didn’t make Sally do, it, Dad, she just did it herself. Yes, I gave her some money. But I didn’t do it.”

There is House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy vowing revenge. “You just wait, Billy. I’m gonna get you real bad.” How is that laudable?

Being a grown-up is hard.

Clearly the Republicans are no longer interested in doing hard things. Like taking responsibility and holding a higher moral standard.

It has become the party that would flunk kindergarten.

•••

Meanwhile, Democrats Fail Math – Latest on President Biden’s Build Back Better social infrastructure program is that the House could take up a vote as early as today or Friday (believe it when you see it). “If there’s any chance of preserving their majority,” Punchbowl News says, referring to the midterms now less than a year away, “House Democrats will have to get BBB passed and on to the Senate. They will deal with whatever is sent back their way.”

Note: Remember when progressive House Democrats, backed by Speaker Nancy Pelosi, held bipartisan infrastructure hostage, saying they wouldn’t vote for the bill until BBB was passed along with it, which of course requires backing from Sens. Joe Manchin III, D-WV, and Krysten Sinema, D-AZ, and, oh by the way, we should double that to $6 trillion? If the House had passed bipartisan infrastructure in September, the progs would have had these last two months, and potentially some goodwill from bipartisan infrastructure, to sort out the social programs bill.

Prediction: “Whatever is sent back” will be a reduction from $1.75 trillion to Manchin’s ceiling of $1.5 trillion, if it’s sent back to the House at all.

•••

January 6 Tourist Sentenced to 41 Months – Jacob Hensley, the spear-carrying January 6 Capitol insurrectionist seen all over cable news with a horned fur hat, bare chest and face paint, was sentenced to 41 months in prison Wednesday after pleading “guilty” to felony charges of obstructing an official proceeding, the AP reports. Hensley, of Arizona, was one of the first to enter the Capitol and has received the longest sentence so far among 38 rioters prosecuted. 

“I have no excuse, no excuse whatsoever,” Hensley told the judge. “My behavior is indefensible.” (So was his attire on January 6.) His attorney had tried to get Hensley credit for the 10 months he has spent in jail over the case.

Note: Meanwhile, former Trump campaign advisor Steve Bannon has pleaded not guilty to criminal contempt of Congress charges and is free (though he had to give up his passport to federal authorities) to continue posting his fiery pro-MAGA podcasts (CNN).

•••

One More from the House of Kindergarten – Kyle Rittenhouse, 18, “would probably make a good congressional intern,” Rep. Max Gaetz, R-FL, told Newsmax Wednesday, according to The Washington Post, which has apparently found a reporter willing to stomach the pro-Trump cable “news” outlet. Yes, that Kyle Rittenhouse, who faces potential life in prison if he’s found guilty of homicide in the fatal shooting of two people in last year’s Kenosha, Wisconsin, protests. Of course, upon his arrest (when he was still 17), Rittenhouse quickly became a hero on extremist outlets. The jury in his trial began their third day of deliberations today.

--Edited by Todd Lassa and Gary S. Vasilash

_____________________________________

WED 11/17/21

President Biden promotes the bipartisan infrastructure program today at General Motors’ electric vehicle assembly plant in Hamtramck, Michigan (NPR). Meanwhile, House Democrats are considering removal of a tax credit for union-built EVs (like those to be built in Hamtramck) from Biden’s $1.75-trillion Build Back Better plan in order to promote passage by the Senate(Roll Call).

Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-NY, wants a vote on the Build Back Better bill by Christmas, though Sen. Joe Manchin III, D-WV, is pushing to waive it off until next year (NBC News). The House is scheduled to vote on it (very) late this week.

The U.S. plans to buy 10 million Pfizer and Merck COVID-19 pills, which officials believe could be a pandemic game-changer (WaPo).

The prosecution wrapped yesterday, and now defense presents its case in the Georgia trial of the killing of Ahmaud Arbery, as the Wisconsin jury in the case of Kyle Rittenhouse enters its second day of deliberations.

House to Vote on Censuring Gosar – Rep. Paul Gosar, R-AZ, the former dentist whose two brothers and a sister (out of nine siblings) have called for his resignation, is up for House censure in a vote today, according to Politico, over an animated video posted online depicting Gosar fatally stabbing Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-NY, in the neck. Gosar also is shown about to attack President Biden in the cartoon video reportedly posted by the congressman’s staff. Along with the censure, the House will vote on removing Gosar from his committee assignments, a la Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, R-GA, who lost her assignments way back in February for pro-QAnon postings prior to running for Congress. 

MTG, meanwhile, is pushing Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy, R-CA, to strip 13 House Republican “traitors” who voted for Biden’s bipartisan infrastructure bill of their committee assignments.

Note: Pundit chatter points to this dichotomy as evidence the GOP is as much in disarray as the Democratic Party, though of a disarray particular to Republicans. McCarthy was once a relatively moderate Republican himself – he’s from California, after all – but now he must consider giving in to MTG’s (and thus Donald J. Trump’s) wishes, as the House Democratic majority votes to censure and strop Gosar, anyway. 

Meanwhile, cable news stations and other outlets that are not Fox News report on House Republicans who voted against bipartisan infrastructure but are touting bridge repairs and the like they are bringing home to constituents. 

Bottom Line: No matter what McCarthy does to stifle the increasingly loud arguments between his party’s factions, no pundits are backing off the presumption that a GOP massacre in next November’s House midterms will shift power to Republicans. The guarantee of a GOP House is not a guarantee of McCarthy as House speaker, however – if a majority of a Republican House majority are pro-Trumpers, there remains a real chance the former president, and not McCarthy, would replace Nancy Pelosi.

•••

Rep. Speier Announces Retirement – Rep. Jackie Speier, D-CA, announced she will not seek re-election in next year’s midterms, per Roll Call. Speier, 71, ran for the House of Representatives after she was shot by members of the Peoples Temple cult at Jonestown in Guyana in 1978. Her boss, Rep. Leo J. Ryan, was killed at the airport there following the massacre of 37 cult members. Speier currently holds senior positions on the House Armed Services and Intelligence committees, and chairs subcommittees on both. 

--Edited by Todd Lassa and Nic Woods

_____________________________________

TUE 11/16/21

Retail sales rose 1.7% in October, the Commerce Department reports, a stronger showing than expected and compared with an 0.8% increase for September. The latest numbers provide much-needed good economic news for the White House.

Former Trump adviser Steve Bannon was released Monday after turning himself in to the FBI in Washington, D.C., over Contempt of Congress charges. He faces up to $200,000 in fines and two years in jail if convicted, NPR reports, and was required to turn in his passport.

Jury deliberations have begun in the Kyle Rittenhouse case in Kenosha, Wisconsin.

In a Washington Post-ABC News poll, 65% said the Supreme Court should overturn Texas’ abortion law restricting the procedure after the sixth week of pregnancy, and 60% believe Roe v. Wade should be upheld. SCOTUS will consider December 1 a Mississippi law restricting abortions after 15 weeks.

Social Infrastructure Vote Saturday? – The House vote on the Build Back Better plan, President Biden’s $1.75-trillion social infrastructure bill, could slip to Saturday, The Hill reports, citing a “senior Democrat source.” Considering how the House dragged out the bipartisan infrastructure vote, Saturday seems pretty optimistic, though the Thanksgiving break looms. 

The non-partisan Congressional Budget Office promises its price tag on the bill by end of the day Friday. What’s the over-under on a Sunday vote?

Note: Forget the comparisons with FDR and LBJ over Build Back Better. Thanks largely to the 6.2% U.S. inflation rate, Biden is now being compared with Jimmy Carter.

•••

Pep Rally for Biden’s BIF Signature – Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-KY, was busy, as promised, with other matters. But Sen. Lisa Murkowski, R-AK, who is gearing up for a Trump-picked primary challenger in next year’s midterms, and Sen. Rob Portman, R-OH, who already has announced he will not run for re-election, both attended President Biden’s bipartisan infrastructure bill-signing ceremony Monday afternoon. 

House Republicans Don Young, of Alaska (who is not seeking re-election) and Tom Reed, of New York (who is) also attended.

Biden has chosen former New Orleans Mayor Mitch Landrieu to be his infrastructure czar. He and Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg will administer the $1.75-trillion infrastructure budget, $550 billion of which is new spending. 

At the ceremony, Portman had this to say about attacks against the 13 Republican representatives and 19 Republican senators who voted for the bill, which Donald J. Trump has criticized though he had proposed a similar $1 trillion package during his many “Infrastructure Weeks” as president: “Finding common ground to advance the interests of the American people should be rewarded, not attacked.” (Per NPR’s All Things Considered.)

Portman said bipartisan infrastructure will help create jobs and reduce inflation, which might be enough of a win for Biden no matter how his social infrastructure bill goes down.

•••

Wonder Where the Flat Screen Was Made – The virtual summit between President Biden from the Oval Office, a big flat screen to his left broadcasting the video call, and Chinese President Xi Jingping from Beijing went on for more than three hours Monday night. The two discussed Afghanistan, North Korea, Iran, human rights, climate change and Taiwan but did not produce any major resolutions, according to White House officials (from The Wall Street Journal’s report).

Biden told Xi he remains committed to the “One China” policy, according to White House officials, though he added the U.S. “strongly opposes unilateral efforts to change the status quo or undermine peace and stability across the Taiwan Strait.”

•••

On Christie’s Republican Rescue Effort – Though former New Jersey Republican Gov. Chris Christie has yet to announce a run for the GOP presidential nomination in 2024, he is making the rounds of non-Fox News media outlets in a tour for his new book, Republican Rescue. Though this Republican comeback kid, a sort of GOP counterpart to former perennial presidential candidate Joe Biden, wrote the book to pick a fight and distance himself from former President Trump, the punditocracy isn’t very sympathetic. Christie was one of the earliest mainstream Republicans to support Trump’s 2016 run and was an advisor early in the administration.

The big question though is whether Christie’s re-emergence as a never-in-2024-Trumper is any indication that the GOP is backing away – however slowly – from the former president. On MSNBC’s The 11th Hour Monday, Christie cited the Des Moines Register’s Iowa Poll showing that 61% of self-identified Republicans say they have more allegiance to the GOP than to Donald Trump (26%). 

Note: Though The 11th Hour host Brian Williams pressed Christie on his fervid loyalty to Trump through most of the administration, Williams didn’t ask him about the polls over the past 10 months – countering the latest Iowa poll -- that show a vast majority of the nation’s Republicans believe Donald J. Trump’s Big Lie.

•••

Alex Jones Found Liable in Sandy Hook Case – Infowars host Alex Jones must pay eight families who filed a lawsuit against him for defamation over the Sandy Hook school shooting, The Washington Post reports. Jones had made up stories that families of the 26 killed at the Newton, Connecticut elementary school were paid actors who “faked” the shooting. The judge in the case found for the plaintiffs after Jones refused to turn over documents related to the case.

--Edited by Todd Lassa and Charles Dervarics

____________________________________

MON 11/15/21

Big Monday for President Biden, who signs the $1.2 trillion bipartisan infrastructure bill at 3 p.m. and holds a virtual meeting this evening with Chinese President Xi Jinping.

Stephen K. Bannon turned himself in to the FBI’s Washington field office Monday after the Justice Department indicted the former Trump adviser with two counts of contempt of Congress, for failing to respond to a subpoena from the 1/6 House select committee (NPR).

Build Back Better This Week? – Democrats in the House of Representatives expect to pass President Biden’s $1.75 trillion social safety net Build Back Better bill this week, but “this week” could mean “by the weekend” or even “early next week.” Whether even “this year” is realistic, Congress members’ desire to take their Thanksgiving week break adds extra pressure, according to Punchbowl News. Progressives and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-CA, want a vote this week, and moderates led by Rep. Josh Gottheimer, D-NJ, “see no reason for a delay” on the vote, according to the Punchbowl News report. 

And Then There’s the CBO: However, the Congressional Budget Office is expected to update today its timetable for the scoring of the BBB. Moderate Democrats, including Sen. Joe Manchin III of West Virginia, want to see that the program is fully funded. The CBO probably won’t release anything until Thursday. 

Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-NY, says the Senate cannot complete its “Byrd Bath” until it receives the CBO report, anyway. So the bill potentially could sit in the Senate between Thanksgiving and New Year’s 2022.

The ‘Byrd Bath’ is – Late-Sen. Robert Byrd’s, D-WV, rule that prevents extraneous provisions tacked on to a budget reconciliation bill, and thus potentially be approved without filibuster challenges. Byrd sponsored the rule, which the Senate adopted in 1985-86, according to Congressional Research Service.

Fun Fact: Upon Byrd’s death in 2010, then-Gov. Joe Manchin, D, of West Virginia, named Carte Goodwin to fill out the rest of his term. When Goodwin chose not to run for re-election in November 2010, Manchin ran for the Senate seat himself. The rest is Democratic Party history.

•••

There Will be Oil – At what price? Gasoline and diesel, and home heating oil prices are at the forefront of inflation fears that continue to dog President Biden’s agenda. Opposition to his Build Back Better program, now set at $1.9 trillion, is tied to the 6.2% annual inflation rate the Commerce Department reported last week. 

Republicans and other opponents of the Build Back Better program say they worry this part of Biden’s agenda, in particular, will only fuel the high inflation rate. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellin says inflation will come down as supply chains open up next year. In other words, the beginning, or the middle, or worst-case scenario for the Democrats, near the end of the midterm elections.

But oil prices tend to be controlled by Big Oil. There are no signs yet of delivery problems to the pump. AAA, by the way, says the national average price of regular gas is $3.415/gallon as of Monday, up from $2.126/gal November 15, 2020. Diesel averages $3.646/gal, versus $2.386/gal a year ago.

United Nations Climate Change Summit, Blah, Blah, Blah: Big Oil has been in a constant fight for years to slow the advance of the renewable energy industry. Oil price spikes come at the convergence of a restart of world economies after the pandemic shutdown and of the fairly ineffective COP26 United Nations climate change conference in Glasgow, Scotland. The nations did not meet summit goals of a plan to reduce global warming by 1.5 degrees Celsius per year.

According to The Washington Post, the COP26 summit ended last weekend with nearly 200 countries agreeing to ramp up carbon-cutting commitments, phase out some fossil fuels and increase aid to poorer countries to help them convert to renewable energy sources. But language to “phase out” coal was watered down to “phase down” coal after a last-minute request by the world’s two most populous countries, China and India.

•••

Washington Real Estate News – The Trump Organization is selling its lease for its hotel in Washington, D.C.’s Old Post Office for $375 million, The Wall Street Journal scooped over the weekend. Subject of House committee investigations and hearings on conflicts of interest and the emoluments clause involving former President Trump, the hotel’s lease was sold to CGI Merchant Group, a Miami-based investment firm. The federal government still owns the building.

Elsewhere within the District, friend-of-Trump Peter Thiel has been identified by Politico as the purchaser of Wilbur and Hilary Geary Ross’ 10,000-square-foot house in the Woodland-Normanstone neighborhood for $13 million. Wilbur Ross was Trump’s Commerce secretary. Thiel is the German co-founder of PayPal, who secretly funded Hulk Hogan’s lawsuit against Gawker.com, putting the media outlet out of business, and was known for his speech praising Trump at the 2016 GOP Convention. He has made separate $10 million donations to super PACs supporting the 2022 House candidacies of J.D. Vance in Ohio and Blake Masters in Arizona, according to Politico.

Note: The soon-to-be ex-Trump Hotel (no recounts, please) may go from being a meeting place for Republican power brokers to a meeting place for Democratic and Republican power brokers. The former Ross residence? Not so much.

•••

Leahy to Retire – Vermont’s senior U.S. senator, Democrat Patrick Leahy, 84, has announced he will not run for re-election in 2022, NPR reports. Leahy is serving his eighth term in the Senate.

•••

O’Rourke Shoots for Texas Gubernatorial Race – Will his third campaign be a charm? Former El Paso congressman Beto O’Rourke has announced he will run for the Democratic nomination to challenge Republican Gov. Gregg Abbott’s re-election next year, The Texas Tribune reports. O’Rourke conducted a high-profile challenge to Texas Sen. Ted Cruz, R, in 2018, and entered the race for the Democratic presidential nomination last year.

--Edited by Todd Lassa and Nic Woods

_____
Please email your comments to editors@thehustings.news

We are building an alternative social media site so you can read various points of view outside of the usual echo-chambers and submit your civil comments without fear of trolling or being flooded with suggestions to join extremist “news” outlets and organizations from the left or right. 

Unlike the Big Social Media sites, we do not hide behind Section 230, the law that protects such sites from libelous posts submitted by their readers. The Hustings is on Thanksgiving recess until December 1, but we will still be looking for your comments to post in the left or right column. 

Please send your comments on our debates and News & Notes to editors@thehustings.news and tell us whether you consider yourself “left” or “right.”

Email us your comments on …

•The $1.75 trillion Build Back Better social infrastructure bill, HR 5376, passed by the House of Representatives just before the chamber took its Thanksgiving week recess. The bill now proceeds to the Senate, which could vote on it as early as December, but more likely January. Any Senate amendments will send the bill back to the House before it can be sent to the Oval Office for President Biden’s signature. 

Our flash debate on the question of whether the January 6 Capitol insurrection was “dress rehearsal” for the 2024 presidential election.

Observations by Stephen Macaulay and Bryan Williams on Republican Glenn Youngkin’s Virginia gubernatorial election victory.

Keep scrolling and you eventually will find our first home-page debates, covering the Fall 2020 presidential debates between Joe Biden and then-President Trump.

_____________________________________

Your Arguments Against BBB Here

The House of Representatives has passed the $1.75-trillion Build Back Better social infrastructure bill, HR 5376. The bill now proceeds to the Senate, which could vote on it as early as December, but more likely January. Any Senate amendments will send the bill back to the House before it goes to the Oval Office for President Biden’s signature. 

What do you think of the bill? Will it fuel or slow inflation? Will it reverse 40 years of Reaganomics? Help continue the conversation and send your comments to editors@thehustings.news. Please keep it civil and tell us whether you are left or right. 

Join our effort to provide an alternative to Big Social Media.

Scroll down to read, and comment on more:

Stephen Macaulay’s commentary in this column on ex-President Trump’s Chief of Staff Mark Meadows’ claim of executive privilege in his attempt to avoid testifying before the January 6 House select committee.

The Hustings debate, “Was January 6 a ‘Dress Rehearsal’?” with news and analysis on the issue in the middle column, and commentary in the left and right columns.

Observations by Stephen Macaulay and Bryan Williams on Republican Glenn Youngkin’s Virginia gubernatorial election victory.

_____

If you’re reading this left column because you consider yourself liberal, the answer probably is “no.” 

If you’re reading this left column because you consider yourself conservative but want to avoid 'echo-chamber' news and politics, an explanation of Stephen Macaulay’s right-column might be in order. Macaulay is The Hustings’ pundit-at-large and as such he has written for both left and right columns. He’s written commentary for the right column, mostly, though as a never-Trumper, Macaulay has commented from this left column opposite pro-Trump and formerly pro-Trump contributors. 

The Hustings encourages you to comment on this issue so we can continue the conversation in these columns. When you comment to editors@thehustings.news, please let us know whether your political philosophy puts you to the left or to the right of the news items and issues of the center column. 

While you’re here, don’t forget to scroll down to read our flash debate on whether the January 6 Capitol insurrection was a “dress rehearsal” for what President Trump and his supporters might have planned for 2024. Note that while The Hustings strives for fair and equal political discourse, we are unabashedly pro-democracy.

--Todd Lassa

_____

FRI 11/12/21

The White House has confirmed that President Biden and Chinese President Xi Jinping will hold a virtual summit Monday.

The UN Climate Conference is scheduled to conclude today, although it could be extended if COP26 doesn’t produce a deal among participants (which do not include China and Russia) to end fossil fuel and coal use by a date certain (WaPo).

Was January 6 a ‘dress rehearsal’? Is ex-President Trump planning a coup for 2024? Read the issues by scrolling down to the next item, and join the conversation by emailing your comments to editors@thehustings.news.

Trump Wins Delay on 1/6 Documents – Donald J. Trump’s biggest success as a businessman, beside his 15 seasons as host of The Apprentice was perhaps his ability to file lawsuits and delay those for which he was being sued. That lawsuit success streak continued Thursday when a federal appeals court temporarily blocked the National Archives from turning over call logs, draft speeches and other documents related to the January 6 Capitol insurrection, to the House select committee investigating the riot (NPR’s Morning Edition).

The court has set a date of November 30 to hear arguments in former President Trump’s lawsuit to block their release, under the guise of “executive privilege.”

Note: This turned into the Washington image of a suspense novel yesterday, as the 1/6 committee seeking the documents were waiting out a Saturday deadline for the National Archives to turn them over. Most pundits say that while the case is likely to keep the documents out of the committee’s hands until the end of this year, it could extend into 2022, with the Supreme Court possibly being called upon to make the final rule. We’d say that a delay to next year, when primaries for the midterms begin, seems inevitable.

But don’t take any extra meaning beyond this: “The purpose of the administrative injunction is to protect the court’s jurisdiction to address [Trump’s] claims of executive privilege and should not be construed in any way as a ruling on the merits,” the judges said in its brief, per The Hill.

•••

Putting the ‘Bi’ in ‘Bipartisan’ – Minority Leader Mitch McConnell of Kentucky was one of 19 Senate Republicans who voted for President Biden’s $1.2 trillion bipartisan infrastructure bill – the BIF – way back in September, and now he’s defending the 13 Republicans who helped push it over the top in the House of Representatives’ 228-206 vote one week ago. In a Kentucky radio show interview McConnell called the BIF “good for the country,” Newsweek reports, even after House Republicans also in-favor have received death threats, apparently from those who don’t like to see the party hand Biden any legislative victories.

To the MAGA crowd, complete gridlock is good.

McConnell’s comity only goes so far. He has no plans to attend Monday’s Oval Office signing ceremony. “I’ve got other things I’ve got to do,” he said. Presumably, McConnell might have found the time for a Trump signing ceremony had any of the ex-president’s Infrastructure Weeks produced anything.

•••

Florida Men – Speaking of the de facto leader of the GOP, Donald J. Trump is complaining to guests and members of Mar-a-Lago that Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis hasn’t joined the club of 2024 Republican presidential hopefuls in saying he won’t run for president if the former president chooses to run again for a second term, according to scoopage from Politico. Trump also suggested DeSantis shouldn’t underestimate his 2022 Democratic challenger for Florida governor, Charlie Crist, the former independent, and former Republican before that. 

[No mention by Trump of “Little Marco” Rubio’s prospects for re-election to the U.S. Senate in Florida next year, where Democratic Rep. Val Demings outraised the incumbent in the third quarter, $8.3 million to $6 million.]

Meanwhile, in the House, Politico reports that Rep. Kevin McCarthy’s, R-CA, expected ascension to House Speaker after next November’s midterms will be tougher for having to deal with his caucus’ conservatives and “wild cards.” 

Note: Bottom line is that if Trump’s support is indeed crumbling among Republican senators, he still has the House. Question is whether that support will hold as Republican Senators attempt to move on.

This Just In: Sen. Lisa Murkowski, R-AK, a moderate, announced Friday morning she will run for re-election. She faces Trump’s primary challenger, Kelly Tshibaka, the former commissioner for the state’s Department of Administration. Murkowski, who has served in the Senate since 2002, when her father appointed her to finish his term, was one of seven Republicans to vote to convict Trump in the trial of his second impeachment, earlier this year.

--Edited by Todd Lassa and Nic Woods

_____
Please email your comments to editors@thehustings.news

By Stephen Macaulay

Joe Biden “is the first President to make no effort whatsoever to protect presidential communications from being the subject of compelled testimony. Mr. Meadows remains under the instructions of former President Trump to respect longstanding principles of executive privilege. It now appears the courts will have to resolve this conflict.”

That from former Trump Chief of Staff Mark Meadows’ attorney George Terwilliger III, according to The Washington Post.

The House Select Committee investigating the January 6 mayhem at the Capitol has requested documents from Meadows (as well as his appearance in front of the committee).

It would be a cheap shot based on the attorney’s name that there seems to be a difference between the rich and powerful and the rest of us. I’ll take it.

If you were served a subpoena by the United States House of Representatives, I’m guessing that following a reaction of “oh shit,” you’d clear your calendar.

But Meadows, as well as several other Trump acolytes, seem to think that they must listen to their liege and they are above doing what the rest of us would be obligated to do.

Let’s think about Terwillger’s quote. “[T]he first President to make no effort whatsoever to protect presidential communication from being the subject of compelled testimony.” First, that seems to be a rather extensive claim. Second, when else did we have a president who reportedly sat watching TV while the U.S. Capitol was under attack and chose not to do anything about it until he was good and ready, and at that point made what is arguably a mealy-mouthed recommendation that the anarchists go home. (No, those people who attacked the Capitol are not anarchists in the true sense of the word, as anarchists would not storm against the government on behalf of a politician, but seeing as how the Republicans imprecisely bandy about the term “socialist,” fair is fair, unless you are Trump, and fairness is what he says it is.)

Then there’s “under the instructions of former President Trump.” That adjective means “previous.” Trump is no longer president. He is, which may come as a surprise to some people, a regular citizen. Meadows might as well be under the instructions of Ryan Seacrest.

The “longstanding principles of executive privilege” is also rich.

The Presidential Oath of Office includes the phrase, “preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of the United States.”

On January 6, the U.S. Congress was fulfilling its duties under the Constitution. So to protect Congress would be to “preserve, protect and defend the Constitution.”

Somehow one could argue that (1) not only does executive privilege end when someone is no longer in charge of the Executive Branch, but (2) the abrogation of his responsibilities on January 6 — and does any doubt that his inaction that afternoon contributed to things like, oh, the vice president’s life being put in danger — makes that privilege, under these circumstances, laughable.

_____
Please email your comments to editors@thehustings.news

Use the scrollbar to scroll past today’s News & Notes to read The Hustings debate, “Was January 6 a ‘Dress Rehearsal’?” with news and analysis on the issue in the middle column, and commentary in the left and right columns.

_____
Please email your comments to editors@thehustings.news

THU 11/11/21

The Tomb of the Unknowns marks its 100th anniversary at Arlington National Cemetery and is open to the public for the first time in 96 years, for just two days, NPR says.

President Biden will sign the $1.2 trillion bipartisan infrastructure bill Monday, The Hill reports.

A federal judge has approved a $626 million settlement of civil claims regarding the Flint, Michigan, water crisis. Nearly 80% of the settlement is for children, but it does not settle all lawsuits over lead contamination in the city’s water, Michigan Public Radio reports.

Scroll down to read a new comment in the right column regarding our ongoing debate, ‘Was January 6 a ‘Dress Rehearsal’?” It’s not too late to add your own comments to the left or right columns – email us at editors@thehustings.news.

Insurrection vs. Inflation – District Judge Tanya Chutkan refused to delay the Friday deadline for the National Archives to turn over Trump White House documents to the January 6 House select committee, while the former president appeals the judge’s decision of earlier in the week (The Hill). Meanwhile, President Biden spoke of easing up supply shipping bottlenecks with the passage of his $1.2 trillion bipartisan infrastructure bill, after the Labor Department yesterday released news of the highest annual Consumer Price Index in 30 years.

What do these two issues have to do with each other?

If Donald J. Trump’s attorneys can’t get the Supreme Court to stay the district judge’s decision before the White House documents are turned over to Rep. Bennie Thompson’s, D-MS, committee tomorrow, much will be revealed about the president and his advisers’ involvement in the Capitol insurrection. 

If, on the other hand, Trump manages more delay, the select committee will get stalled probably well into 2022. Next year, coincidentally, is when Treasury Secretary Janet Yellin expects inflation to come down to normal levels while the White House holds out high hopes that bipartisan infrastructure will help fix the supply chain bottleneck and all those container ships stacked up off U.S. coasts. 

Known knowns: Sen. Joe Manchin III, D-WV, is highly unlikely to let the $1.8 trillion Build Back Better social safety net plan go anywhere, especially after the dire CPI numbers. 

Known unknowns: The House of Representatives is scheduled to vote on the safety net bill next week. But it’s unlikely to advance, at least in the Senate, until next year if at all, depending on how the inflation rate plays out in coming months. By the time that happens, the House select committee either will, or will not, have scrutinized Trump’s White House papers.

Unknown unknowns: House Republicans who support Trump want to strip the 13 moderate House Republicans who voted for the bipartisan infrastructure bill of their committee assignments, even though the bill has widespread support across the country, as it fixes roads and bridges – and ports – while boosting employment levels. The Trumpists do not want to hand Biden any victories, especially as his poll numbers plummet -- a USA Today/Morning Consult poll released yesterday says Biden’s approval rating has dropped to a Trump-like low of 38%. 

They also want to root out moderate House Republicans (many of whom, including Illinois’ Adam Kinzinger, one of only two GOP members on the 1/6 committee, have already announced they will not run for re-election) on their way to a much-expected route of Democrats in next November’s mid-terms.

Known known II: If the 1/6 select committee struggles next year with Trump’s stall tactics, and the inflation rate and struggling economy hands the GOP a turnover of the House, its new speaker, Kevin McCarthy, R-CA, will dismantle the committee.

•••

House Dems Hope to Censure Gosar — A group of House Democrats will offer a resolution to censure Paul Gosar, R-AZ, which, if accepted, would have the consequence of Gosar having to stand in the well of the House as the censure is read out by Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-CA. Gosar posted “an edited video on social media depicting himself as murdering Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and attacking President Joe Biden,” according to Punchbowl News.

Note: Gosar is 62 and generally considered to be a grown-up. An edited anime with one of his colleagues being killed and the president of the United States being attacked is something that one might imagine a pimply-faced teen to post. Yes, this is what it comes to in the political entity formerly known as the “Grand Old Party.” There is nothing grand about it. Stupid, perhaps. Incidentally: Gosar’s former career was as a dentist. The mind boggles.

•••

There’s Always Chris – Former New Jersey governor, “friend” of Donald J. Trump, and likely 2024 presidential candidate Chris Christie told the Republican Jewish Coalition in Las Vegas last weekend that it’s time for the GOP to focus on future fights rather than rehash the 2020 election, Axios reports in a preview of an exclusive interview for an upcoming HBO show. 

Predictably, Trump put out a statement that Christie “was just absolutely massacred by his statements that Republicans have to move on from the past.” Christie left New Jersey with a record-low approval rating of just 9%, Trump continued, without explaining why he would have relied on such a disliked politician for his 2016 campaign. 

Note: Good news for never-Trump Republicans, Democrats and other defenders of democracy is that Christie’s almost inevitable ’24 run will make it hard for Trump to hold on to all but his most loyal acolytes over the next three years.

•••

Obituary: F.W. de Klerk, South Africa’s Last Apartheid President – The last president of South Africa’s Apartheid regime, F.W. de Klerk, has died after battling cancer at his home near Cape Town Thursday, age 85. De Klerk served as South Africa’s president from 1989 to 1994, when he lost re-election to the formerly imprisoned African National Congress leader, Nelson Mandela. The two men shared the 1993 Nobel Peace Prize. While de Klerk apologized for Apartheid, the question remains of whether he sufficiently rejected its moral injustice.

--Edited by Todd Lassa, Gary S. Vasilash and Nic Woods

____________________________________

WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2021

Scroll down for our debate on whether the January 6 Capitol insurrection was a ‘dress rehearsal’ for Donald J. Trump’s return in 2024. Submit your comments to editors@thehustings.news.

Inflation Rate Hits 30-year High – Consumer Price Index was up 6.2% for the last 12 months, the highest annual inflation rate since 1991, the U.S. Labor Department reported Wednesday. The CPI rose 0.9% in October, versus 0.4% in September. The Labor Department cited price increases in a wide array of consumer goods, though energy, shelter, food, used and new cars and trucks “were among the larger contributors.”

•••

Judge Rejects Trump’s Lawsuit to Block 1/6 Papers – Federal Judge Tanya Chutkan has denied former President Trump’s lawsuit seeking to block the National Archives’ release of documents related to the January 6 Capitol insurrection to the House Select Committee investigating the riot. In her 39-page ruling, the judge said there is a public interest in releasing the documents (The Hill).

“Presidents are not kings, and Plaintiff is not president,” Chutkan said.

Note: While the House Select Committee hopes to procure the documents as early as this Friday, Trump’s attorneys have promised to appeal, and the case is likely headed to the Supreme Court. If Trump’s lawyers can draw out the case well into 2022, a long delay could come after the midterm elections, when Republicans expect to retake the House majority and a new speaker, Rep. Kevin McCarthy, R-CA, would likely dissolve the 1/6 investigation.

•••

Meanwhile, 1/6 Committee Subpoenas 10 More Trump Associates – The House select committee investigating the January 6 Capitol insurrection has issued 10 more subpoenas, to former Trump administration officials. They are, per The Wall Street Journal:

•Kayleigh McEnany: Trump White House press secretary.

•Stephen Miller: Senior advisor, and key advocate for administration’s immigration policy.

•Chris Liddell: Former White House deputy chief of staff.

•Nicholas Luna: Trump personal assistant (“luggage carrier”).

•John McEntee: Former White House personnel director.

•Ben Williamson: Trump assistant and senior advisor to ex-Chief of Staff Mark Meadows.

•Keith Kellogg: Ex-Vice President Pence’s security advisor.

•Cassidy Hutchinson: Special assistant to ex-President Trump for legislative affairs.

•Molly Michael: Special assistant to the ex-president, and former Oval Office operations co-ordinator.

•Kenneth Klukowski: Former senior council to ex-Assistant Attorney General Jeffrey Clark.

•••

Sununu Rejects Senate Run – Republican New Hampshire Gov. Chris Sununu has rejected pleas by GOP Senate leadership to run against Sen. Maggie Hassan, D-NH, in next year’s midterms. Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-KY, and Sen. Rick Scott, R-FL, considered Sununu their best chance for retaking the chamber’s majority after November 2022, Politico notes. 

Sununu is the younger brother of former Sen. John Sununu, who lost re-election to Democrat Jeanne Shaheen in 2008. Shaheen, a former governor who lost her first run against John Sununu in 2002, became the first Democratic U.S. senator from New Hampshire since 1981 when she took the seat in 2009.

Note: The pols have it that Sununu finds it easier to be a Republican governor with a distant relationship to Donald J. Trump, like Virginia Gov.-elect Glenn Youngkin, than to potentially run against a hand-picked Trump candidate for the Republican Senate primary next year.

•••

Obituary: Max Cleland – Former U.S. Sen. Max Cleland, D-GA, died Tuesday at the age of 79. As a U.S. Army captain who served during the Vietnam War, he lost both legs and an arm in a grenade accident in 1968. He served as administrator of the Veterans Administration under President Carter from 1977 to 1981, and ran for the Senate in 1996, where he served until January 2003. During his failed bid for a second term, Saxby Chambliss, his Republican opponent ran commercials claiming Cleland was “soft” on terrorism, picturing him side-by-side with a photo of Osama bin Laden. Republican Sens. John McCain, of Arizona and Chuck Hagel, of Nebraska expressed their outrage at their party’s smear campaign at the time.

“I publicly stated that I wanted it stopped,” Hagel later said. “To question Max Cleland’s patriotism was just astounding to me. And these are from people who had never served our country in uniform.” 

--Edited by Todd Lassa and Gary S. Vasilash

_____

Use the scrollbar to scroll past today’s News & Notes to read The Hustings debate, “Was January 6 a ‘Dress Rehearsal’?” with news and analysis on the issue in the middle column, and commentary in the left and right columns.

_____
Please email your comments to editors@thehustings.news

You are invited to add your comments to the left or right column of this page on the question posed in the center column. Please submit your comments to editors@thehustings.news and let us know whether you consider yourself “left” or “right.”

Contributor comments:

America's muted reaction to the January 6th insurrection continues to baffle. Gonzalez's wise warnings should be heeded, unfortunately, we know that they are likely to fall on deaf ears. Congress needs to pass a bill to repair the 1964 Voting Rights Act immediately. 

-Jessica Gottlieb

•••

_____

By Todd Lassa

There is a pervasive notion that the January 6 pro-Trump Capitol insurrection was not a one-off. Given the ongoing commitment among some in the Republican Party to what is now known -- but not by them -- as "The Big Lie," that the 2020 presidential election was "stolen," there is concern that coups tend to fail before they succeed and in 2024 if the election results do not have a Republican presidential victory, there may be another insurrection.

Last Friday, one of the current congress members who has chosen not to run for re-election and face one of Donald J. Trump’s hand-picked primary challengers, Rep. Tony Gonzalez, R-OH, spoke on CNN to warn that January 6 was a “dress rehersal” and that a much better-organized Trump campaign will try again when he runs in 2024.

“January 6 was an unconstitutional attempt led by the President of the United States to overturn an American election and reinstall himself in power illegitimately,” Gonzalez said. “That’s fallen nation territory. That’s third world country territory. My family left Cuba to avoid that fate.

“I will not let it happen here,” Gonzalez continued. “I think it’s all pushing towards one of two outcomes: He either wins legitimately, which he may do, or he loses again, you just try to steal it.”

Gonzalez, a sophomore representative serving for Ohio’s 16th Congressional District was one of 10 Republicans in the House of Representatives to vote for Trump’s second impeachment, over the January 6 insurrection. He announced in September he would not run for a third term.

In a statement released by Trump’s Save America PAC, Gonzalez’s September retirement announcement prompted the ex-president to say, “1 down, 9 to go!” (per Mediaite.)

President Biden and other Democratic leaders have tried to push federal legislation that would restore portions of the 1964 Voting Rights Act that would prevent such state legislation from taking effect, though there is no chance any of the proposed bills would pass the Senate without suspension of the legislative filibuster. 

The question on the table is this: Should Rep. Gonzalez’s warnings be taken seriously? If so, what steps should Congress take – if any – to assure a fair 2024 presidential election?

_____

You are invited to add your comments to the left or right column of this page on the question posed in the center column. Please submit your comments to editors@thehustings.news and let us know whether you consider yourself “left” or “right.”

Contributor comments:

Remember Jacob Chansley, the January 6 rioter, face painted, shirtless, and with a horned hat?  It is not a good look. “Evil clown” comes to mind, especially because of the spear. (Do you think he’d be admitted to Mar-a-Lago?) If 1/6 was a dress rehearsal, here’s hoping for better costumes.

--Stephen Macaulay

•••

Gonzalez is a fool doing nothing more than getting the anger to rise in his base. That is an outrageous and completely false claim and he has not the slightest evidence for it. It is merely one more step in the on-going demonization of Trump voters on the theory that we will be denied in the future and that they will somehow make Biden/Harris look like they have competence.

--David Iwinski

•••

_____

Stephen Macaulay discusses Virginia Gov.-elect Glenn Youngkin’s, R, upset victory of Democrat Terry McAuliffe. Scroll down to our three-column debate.

Also in this column…

• Jim McCraw comments on whether the Build Back Better plan compromises will leave anyone satisfied by $1.75 trillion worth of social programs. 

•David Amaya on the future of nation building by the U.S. government.

Help us build a better social news media site. Send your civil comments on these and News & Notes issues to editors@thehustings.news

_____

11/9/21

According to WaPo political reporter and Peril co-author Robert Costa; “Political reporters are on the democracy beat.” Coming later today in this space, we begin a three-column debate on whether January 6 was a ‘dress rehearsal’ for a potential pro-Trump coup in 2024. Join the conversation and send comments to editors@thehustings.newsPlease be civil.

And the Latest 1/6 Select Committee Subpoenas Go To – The House Select Committee investigating the January 6 Capitol insurrection issued six more subpoenas Monday, as it awaits Attorney Gen. Merrick Garland’s next move on how to handle a contempt of Congress charge against Stephen K. Bannon. As with Bannon, this list of five men and one woman includes no one who was a federal employee, working for the Trump administration – and thus with no basic claim to executive privilege -- when allegedly planning on January 5-6 to overturn the November election in favor of Donald J. Trump. The list, per The New York Times:

Michael Flynn: Former national security advisor to President Trump.

John Eastman: Attorney who drafted the memo on how Trump could use Vice President Pence and Congress to try to invalidate election results.

Bernard Kerik: Former New York City police commissioner who participated in a planning meeting at the Willard Hotel January 5. Then-President Trump in 2020 pardoned Kerik for ethics violation convictions.

Bill Stepien: Trump campaign manager who supervised its conversion into the “stop the steal” campaign.

Jason Miller: Senior advisor to the campaign who participated in the January 5 Willard Hotel meeting.

•Angela McCallum: Trump campaign national executive assistant, she reportedly left a voice mail message for an unknown Michigan state representative asking whether she could “count on” the rep to help appoint an alternative slate of electors.

•••

House GOP Blowback on Infrastructure Vote – Punchbowl News says rank-and-file Republican members of the House of Representatives are pushing leadership to strip of their committee posts 13 GOP colleagues who voted for President Biden’s $1.2-trillion bipartisan infrastructure bill last Friday. The acrimony is reportedly roiling House GOP leadership, all the way up to Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy of California.

Much of the anger is directed at Rep. John Katko, R-NY, who joined 12 other Republicans in the 228-206 passage of the bill and is ranking member on the Homeland Security Committee. Katko also was one of 10 House Republicans to vote for Donald J. Trump’s second impeachment.

Several other Republicans who voted for the bipartisan bill hold ranking committee posts, according to Punchbowl News, and three of the 13 have already announced they will not run for re-election next year.

Note: This is all political, of course. Republican House members are angry that members of their party handed Biden his first major legislative victory, even on a bill that has widespread support across the country. The 13 Republicans gave House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-CA, who lost six progressives on infrastructure, a cushion on the vote. 

•••

Two for SCOTUS Today – In Ramirez v. Collier, the U.S. Supreme Court will rule definitively on the rights of a convict on death row to receive spiritual comfort and advice prior to execution, per SCOTUSblog. The case involves a Texas policy that has excluded all spiritual advisors from the state’s execution chambers.

Also today, in United States v. Vaello-Madero, the court will consider equal protection challenging Puerto Rico’s exclusion from federal safety net programs (SCOTUSblog). The case involves Jose Luis Vaello-Madero, a Puerto Rican-born U.S. citizen who was living in New York City in 2012 when he became seriously ill and began receiving Supplemental Security Income (SSI). When he returned to Puerto Rico to be closer to family, the SSI stopped. While Puerto Rico is U.S. territory, its citizens are excluded from such safety net programs.

•••

Going in the Wrong Direction? — Sixty-two percent of Americans polled by Morning Consult say that the U.S. is headed in the wrong direction. Since early May, when the number was 50%, those thinking that things aren’t going where they are supposed to be has been heading upward. If there is any satisfaction in the numbers, which are compiled each week, it is that on January 15, 2021, those who said “wrong track” was at 79%, a peak.

Note: One of the primary problems of the Biden Administration is a remarkable inability to message. Until that gets fixed the wrong-way perception will not change. It isn’t going to happen by having Biden stand in front of a White House podium intoning a script, but by having enthusiastic people out there talking about things that are going right, whether on Wall Street (how often did Trump take credit for a rising stock market?) or Main Street (the jobs numbers improved, but no Democrats are beating a drum about it).

--Edited by Todd Lassa, Gary S. Vasilash and Charles Dervarics


MONDAY, NOVEMBER 8, 2021

Facebook whistleblower Frances Haugen testifies before the European Parliament in Brussels today, and before French lawmakers in Paris Wednesday; both groups are expected to air their own proposals for changes to the EU’s content moderation rules, called the Digital Services Act (Politico).

The U.S. reopens international borders today to travelers from 33 countries, mostly in Europe, plus Canada and Mexico, who have been vaccinated for COVID-19, and have proof of a recent coronavirus test (WaPo).

Court Blocks Vax Mandate -- The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, in response to a lawsuit filed by a group including Louisiana’s attorney general, ruled that the Biden administration’s vaccine requirement that companies with 100 or more employees (who must be vaccinated or show regular negative COVID tests), which is to go into effect January 4, 2022, is suspended.

Note: The Biden rule is to be implemented through the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), which was put into existence in 1970 under Richard M. Nixon, who, as you may recall was a Republican. And it is worth noting that the 91stCongress (1969-1971) included 243 Democrats and 192 Republicans. Who knew that there could be things done on a bipartisan basis?

While there seems to be glee in Baton Rouge — The Washington Post quotes Jeff Landry, the Republican attorney general of Louisiana saying the court’s action is “a major win for the liberty of job creators and their employees” — there is something to keep in mind.

Presently there are 754,000 deaths in the U.S. attributed to COVID-19. The Biden plan is meant to help mitigate the addition of more people to that role.

And there is something that is Section 5(a)(1) of the Occupational Safety and Health Act, known as the “General Duty Clause.”

According to the General Duty Clause employers are required to provide employees:

"employment and a place of employment which are free from recognized hazards that are causing or are likely to cause death or serious physical harm to his employees...."

Presumably COVID-19 is recognized. The 754,000 deaths were certainly not all workplace related, but it is a known cause of death and physical harm to those who don’t die.

And that is a “major win for the liberty of job creators and their employees”?

•••

Granholm: “All Options on Table,” Including Strategic Energy Reserve – President Biden has not ruled out tapping the Strategic Energy Reserve as petroleum prices spike under pressure from demand and of supply bottlenecks, according to Energy Secretary Jennifer Granholm. “All options are on the table,” Granholm told CNN’s Dana Bash on State of the Union Sunday.

Note: More critical to the Biden administration’s first-year success as bipartisan infrastructure bill spending begins is the price of gasoline, which sits at an average of $3.422 per gallon according to AAA, and of home heating oil, which also is spiking. The problem is related to fears of continued high inflation even as Treasury Secretary Janet Yellin tries to reassure Americans that this is not likely to be the case  next year as employment returns to normal levels and supply chains open up. For now, high energy cost concerns will create more fodder by moderate Democrats and Republicans against the White House’s $2 trillion Build Back Better social safety net package.

•••

And So Infrastructure Has Come to Pass – It seems to have taken the Democratic loss in last week’s Virginia gubernatorial election and a much closer call than polls predicted in the New Jersey governor’s race to finally get the bipartisan infrastructure (BIP) bill passed in the House of Representatives, 228-206, and sent to President Biden’s desk for signing into law. Biden cancelled his usual, short, weekend trip home to Wilmington, Delaware, in order to sign it. 

The House vote included 13 Republicans in favor and six progressive Democrats who voted “nay.” (See The List.)

To keep things straight, this infrastructure bill is the one for which Congress members can go home and tell constituents that roads will be built and bridges fixed; lead water pipes replaced; Amtrak enhanced; and wi-fi installed in rural America. It’s $1.2 trillion, of which $550 billion is new spending and the rest reauthorizes surface transportation and water programs for five years, according to Roll Call.

Note: For months moderate Democrats and some Republicans have urged House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-CA, to allow separate votes on BIP and on Biden’s approximately $2-trillion social safety net Build Back Better (BBB) program set to pass via the reconciliation process. Blockage came from Sens. Joe Manchin III, D-WV, who has already negotiated the package down from $3.5 trillion, and Krysten Sinema, D-AZ. 

But on Friday, when Pelosi had scheduled a vote on both bills, six moderate House Democrats blocked it, Roll Call reports, saying they couldn’t vote for it without a Congressional Budget Office score detailing its costs. Five of the Democrats, Ed Case of Hawaii, Josh Gottheimer of New Jersey, Stephanie Murphy of Florida, Kathleen Rice of New York and Kurt Schrader of Oregon, said if the package remains un-modded “other than technical changes,” they will help forward the package the week of November 15.

But there remain several moving parts, and we’d bet this will get punted into early next year. At least Biden has infrastructure.

The List: (Per The New York Times.)

The “Squad” of progressive Democrats who voted against the BIP Friday:

Jamaal Bowman, New York.

Cori Bush, Missouri.

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, New York.

Ilhan Omar, Minnesota.

Ayanna S. Pressley, Massachusetts.

Rashida Tlaib, Michigan.

Eight Republicans in the Problem Solvers Caucus who voted for the BIP Friday:

Don Bacon, Nebraska.

Brian Fitzpatrick, Pennsylvania.

Andrew Garbarino, New York.

Anthony Gonzalez, Ohio.

John Katko, New York.

Tom Reed, New York.

Christopher H. Smith, New Jersey.

 Fred Upton, Michigan.

Five additional Republicans who voted for the bill:

Adam Kinzinger, Illinois.

Don Young, Alaska.

Nicole Malliotakis, New York.

David B. McKinley, West Virginia.

Jeff Van Drew, New Jersey.

--Edited by Todd Lassa and Gary S. Vasilash

_____________________________________

FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 5, 2021

Pfizer says its experimental antiviral pill for COVID-19 treatment has cut hospitalization and death rates in trials of high-risk adults by nearly 90%. 

The trial in the death of Ahmaud Arbery begins today in a Georgia court.

Funeral for former Secretary of State Colin Powell is held today at Washington National Cathedral.

Scroll down for our debate on the meaning of Republican Glenn Youngkin’s victory in Tuesday’s Virginia gubernatorial race.

Good October Jobs Numbers – Nonfarm payroll in the U.S. increased by 531,000 jobs in October, a return to an employment boom from about 1 million per month in June and July, before stumbling in August and September. The unemployment rate dropped by 0.1 points to 4.6%, according to the Labor Department’s Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS). Leisure and hospitality employment continues its recovery, and the BLS also cites gains in professional and business services, manufacturing and transportation and warehousing, while public education lost jobs.

•••

Is Today Really the Day? – Democrats in the House of Representatives are planning to vote today on the $1.75-trillion budget reconciliation bill and, oh yeah, pass the $1.2-trillion bipartisan infrastructure bill ($550 billion in new spending) the latter of which would head straight for President Biden’s desk.

Questions remained Thursday over process and policy, including how the social spending bill would provide relief to undocumented immigrants, and how to raise the cap on state and local tax deductions without additional benefit to the wealthiest homeowners, Roll Call says. Prescription drug price provisions were also being negotiated so that bill matches an agreement that House and Senate Democrats reached earlier this week. 

New Jersey Democrats also negotiated a deal late Thursday to raise the limit on state and local tax deductions (SALT) to $80,000, according to Roll Call. It was lowered to $10,000 in 2017.

Note: Would this have saved Terry McAuliffe’s failed Virginia gubernatorial candidacy if it happened last week? Probably not. The bipartisan infrastructure bill should give Democrats some hope for their prospects in Senate and House races in next year’s midterm elections, though.

•••

Meanwhile, the Republican Message – Progressive Democrats are hopeful that Sen. Joe Manchin III, D-WV, will come through and support the $1.75-trillion social infrastructure budget reconciliation bill after the House (probably) passes it today along party lines. Sen. Krysten Sinema, D-AZ, the other swing-voter, appears MIA on the issue the last couple of days. 

But Sen. Lindsay Graham, R-SC, put out this warning on Fox News Thursday: “Any Democrat who claims to be a moderate if you vote for the socialist spending package, you will get your ass beat and you deserve it.”

Note:  Graham’s warning isn’t for Manchin nor Sinema, both of whom are not up for re-election to the Senate until 2024, but to moderate House Democrats who must support the social infrastructure bill for it to pass today. 

•••

From the Newspaper that Gave Us ‘Headless Body in Topless Bar’ – The New York Post reports climate change activists “Swarm Joe Manchin’s Maserati as he Tries to Leave Parking Garage.” 

“A gaggle of far-left environmentalists” chased Manchin from his Washington houseboat on the Potomac as he tried to leave a parking garage Thursday. 

Note: The Murdoch-owned New York tabloid says both Manchin and Sinema have been the target of radical environmentalists angry about their balking at the budget reconciliation bill, which contains $550 billion worth of climate change mitigation policy. 

•••

U.S. Justice Dept. Files Suit Against Texas S1 — The U.S. Justice Department has filed a lawsuit against both the State of Texas and the Texas Secretary of State (John B. Scott) “over certain restrictive voting procedures” in Texas Senate Bill 1, claiming that they violate part of Section 208 of the Voting Rights Act [i.e., restricting assistance to voters in the polling booth who are disabled or illiterate] and Section 101 of the Civil Right Act of 1964 [i.e., rejecting mail-in ballots and request forms because of form-filling errors or omissions “that are not material to establishing a voter’s eligibility to cast a ballot].” This essentially means, in the words of Assistant Attorney General Kristen Clarke for the Justice Dept.’s Civil Rights Division: “Laws that impair eligible citizens’ access to the ballot box have no place in our democracy. Texas Senate Bill 1’s restrictions on voter assistance at the polls and on which absentee ballots cast by eligible voters can be accepted by election officials are unlawful and indefensible.”

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton tweeted, in part, “It’s a great and much-needed bill. Ensuring Texas has safe, secure, and transparent elections is a top priority of mine. I will see you in court, Biden!”, according to Politico.

Note: Arguably, there are “safe, secure, and transparent elections” in Texas. As KVUE (Austin, Texas ABC affiliate) reports, “According to records from the Texas Attorney General's Office, there were a total of 534 offenses charged to 154 people (some had multiple offenses)for either mail ballot fraud, assistance fraud or illegal voting since 2004. Among those 534 offenses, 310 were for mail-in ballot fraud, 159 were for assistance fraud and 189 were for illegal voting. A total of 272 charges of the 534 offenses resolved were from 2015 to March 2021. There are also 510 total counts pending prosecution, according to the report.”

According to the most recent figure from the Texas Secretary of State, there are 16,676,353, registered voters, which puts those numbers into context.

--Edited by Todd Lassa and Gary S. Vasilash

_____
Please email your comments to editors@thehustings.news

Bryan Williams discusses Virginia Gov.-elect Glenn Youngkin’s, R, upset victory of Democrat Terry McAuliffe. Scroll down to our three-column debate.

Also in this column…

• Stephen Macaulay comments on whether the Build Back Better plan compromises will leave anyone satisfied by $1.75 trillion worth of social programs. 

•David Iwinski on the future of nation building by the U.S. government.

Help us build a better social news media site. Send your civil comments on these and News & Notes issues to editors@thehustings.news

_____