Up next; Our left column on whether the Build Back Better plan compromises will leave anyone satisfied by $1.75 trillion worth of social programs. Jim McCraw comments from the left. 

Join the conversation and send your comments to editors@thehustings.news

Also in this column ….

•David Amaya on the future of nation building by the U.S. government.

•Our flash debate on the Pandora Papers released by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists. 

•Our flash debate on the controversy surrounding Gen. Mark Milley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff regarding his portrayal in the book Peril, by Bob Woodward and Robert Costa. 

_____

Will anybody – moderate, progressive, conservative – be happy with compromises being made to the social program budget reconciliation bill (now $1.75-trillion), particularly as it continues to hold up the bipartisan infrastructure bill? Go to https://thehustings.news for a debate on the issue. 

Joe Biden met with Pope Francis today, his first as president, though they had met three times before. Officially on the agenda: The coronavirus pandemic, climate change and caring for the poor (WaPo).

On Saturday, Biden attends a Group of 20 meeting before flying to Glasgow, Scotland, for the UN climate change summit. He also meets with French President Emmanuel Macron to try and smooth over the nuclear submarine deal made with Great Britain and Australia earlier this year.

Treats, Not Tricks – The ever-pending bipartisan infrastructure bill has stalled again in the House of Representatives, as progressive Democrats wait to see what Sens. Joe Manchin III, D-WV, and Krysten Sinema, D-AZ, do in the other chamber. The House progressives don’t want to pass both the $550-billion infrastructure bill and the $1.75-trillion Build Back Better social infrastructure reconciliation budget and watch the latter languish in the Senate after it passes in the House. The hostage-holding continues after President Biden made a special appearance on Capitol Hill Thursday to announce his new Build Back Better social infrastructure proposal slightly delaying his flight to Europe.

Note: Who are the hostage-holders? Sinema messaged support for the framework but was not explicit that she would vote for it, Roll Call reports, while Manchin was non-committal before he tweeted out support for the framework. Politico, which calls Biden’s Thursday release of his budget reconciliation framework a “victory,” [GV1] for the president’s agenda noted that Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-VT, initially balked, citing “gaps” in the bill and signaling the House they should hold off on a vote. 

Punchbowl News points to the failure of the House to quickly pass the bipartisan infrastructure bill and the social program reconciliation budget framework because progressives want to see Senate support first. Rep. Pramila Jayapal, D-WA, who might have been thinking of Ronald Reagan’s mantra “trust, but verify,” let it be known that the Congressional Progressive Caucus she leads was not ready. That forced House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-CA, to quickly introduce an extension to December 3 of the 2015 Surface Transportation law that would be otherwise covered by bipartisan infrastructure. It passed in the House, 358-59, and in the Senate by unanimous consent.

Bottom line: Capitol Hill Republicans are giddy over Biden’s inability to convince progressives to pass the infrastructure bill before he flew off to Rome, and the biggest loser is probably Democratic Virginia gubernatorial candidate Terry McAuliffe, who is in a dead heat with Republican candidate Glenn Younkin in most polls (except a Fox News poll, which gives Youngkin a big lead) going into next Tuesday’s election.

•••

What’s in Biden’s $1.75-trillion Budget Plan – President Biden’s moderate- and progressive-friendly social infrastructure program budget reconciliation framework features  the “biggest climate investment in U.S. history,” according to The Washington Post, which outlines …

•$555 billion to cut emissions, including tax credits for business and consumers to switch to sustainable energy sources.

•Expansion of health care coverage to 7 million people.

•Free pre-kindergarten.

•New taxes on those making over $10 million per year.

•••

Representatives of Oil Companies Testify — Executives from ExxonMobil, BP, Chevron, Shell Oil, the American Petroleum Institute and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce testified yesterday to the House Committee on Oversight and Reform. The questioning was largely driven by Democratic lawmakers who claimed the petroleum industry was playing a “role in spreading disinformation about the science of climate change,” The Washington Post reports. WaPo also writes that the execs were questioned about “whether the companies’ current commitments to clean up their acts were enough to forestall dangerous global warming.” 

Note: Odds are that the members of Congress who were at Capitol Hill for the hearing drove there. Odds are that few of them were in electric vehicles. This means that they probably drove there in vehicles with internal combustion engines — with the engines combusting gasoline, not diesel fuel. So given that, here is what happens in the combustion process, as there seems to be a concern with “science”: 

2C8H18 + 25O2 → 16CO2 + 18H2O

As you can see, there’s lots of carbon dioxide. Remember: Gasoline is a hydrocarbon.

While there were accusations that tried to make an equivalence between “Big Oil” and “Big Tobacco” (are there small versions of either?), there is a significant difference: Anyone can go to a chemistry book and see what happens when gasoline is burned. The link between cancer and smoking was not so obvious.

Have oil companies participated in greenwashing? No doubt.

But it would be interesting to know that the lawmakers have in mind regarding how there can be a significant change. There are some 282 million vehicles rolling on U.S. roads right now, the vast majority of which are powered by gasoline.

This is not to say that pollution is a good thing.

But solutions are far more important than rhetoric.

•••

Ex-Gov. Cuomo Charged with Sexual Misconduct Complaint – Former Gov. Andrew Cuomo, D, was charged on Thursday with a criminal misdemeanor complaint charging he groped a female aide inside the executive mansion “for purposes of degrading and gratifying his sexual desires,” reports The New York Times. The complaint was based on the account of one of about one dozen women whose accusations of sexual harassment were the basis of a state attorney general’s report that led to Cuomo’s resignation in August. 

•••

Collins Hits 8,000 in Senate Voting Streak – Sen. Susan Collins, D-ME, cast her 8,000 consecutive vote yesterday. Her vote was to confirm Elizabeth Prelogar as U.S. solicitor general. Collins has not missed a vote since her first in the Senate on January 22, 1997, Roll Call reports, making her the “Cal Ripken of the Senate,” according to Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-KY. She received accolades from both sides of the aisle, and the floor vote was temporarily stopped as confetti flew.

Sen. Chuck Grassley, R-IA, had voted 8,927 times between July 14, 1993 and November 16, 2020, when his streak ended because he had to quarantine when he contracted COVID-19, according to Roll Call. The late Sen. Bill Proxmire, D-WI, holds the record at 10,252 consecutive votes between April 20, 1966 and October 18, 1988.

--Edited by Todd Lassa and Gary S. Vasilash


THURSDAY, OCTOBER 28, 2021

Will anyone – progressive Democrats, moderate Democrats, moderate Republicans – be satisfied with President Biden’s social infrastructure program? No doubt Trumpist Republicans are reveling in Democrats’ lack of discipline. Read our debate by scrolling down to the next item in the three columns, by Jim McCraw in the left column and Stephen Macaulay in the right column, and email your comments to editors@thehustings.news

Disappointment Expected, Delivered – Real gross domestic product (GDP) rose at an annual rate of just 2.0% in the third quarter of the year, according to an advanced estimate by the Commerce Department’s Bureau of Economic Analysis. That’s a severe drop from the second quarter’s 6.7% annual rate and is being blamed on reduced retail sales and services due to the Delta variant of the coronavirus and to supply chain bottlenecks. Economists are expecting healthy GDP growth for the remaining months of the year. Nevertheless, third-quarter GDP growth was low enough to add urgency to the White House’s bipartisan infrastructure bill languishing in the House of Representatives …

•••

I’ve Gotta Fly; Let’s Pass These Bills – President Biden stopped by the Capitol Thursday morning before flying off for Rome with a new $1.75-trillion social spending budget reconciliation bill he expects all Democrats in the House of Representatives to pass, The Washington Post reports. The new social bill framework includes expanded Medicare benefits, clean energy initiatives (just ahead of his attendance Monday at the United Nations climate change conference in Glasgow, Scotland), free pre-kindergarten, child care aid and an extension of the child tax credit. It cuts more extensive Medicare expansion and paid leave for new mothers, WaPo outlines. 

The cut for paid leave had gone from 12 weeks initially proposed in the White House’s $3.5-trillion Build Back Better program, to four weeks, before getting spiked altogether.

Presumably, Biden’s latest and maybe final proposal accounts for the ever-shifting demands of Sens. Joe Manchin III, D-WV, and Krysten Sinema, D-AZ. If Biden can get the House to pass both the social spending bill and the $1.2 trillion bipartisan infrastructure bill ($550 billion in new spending), the infrastructure bill would be ready to deliver to his desk for signing.

The social program budget reconciliation framework would be completely offset by taxes on multinational corporations’ overseas profits, a minimum tax on the nation’s largest corporations, a surcharge on the highest-income households and new IRS enforcement, Roll Call reports. 

Biden is on Air Force One today headed for Rome to meet with Pope Francis. He is also scheduled to meet with French President Emmanuel Macron before heading to Glasgow[CD1]  Sunday for the UN climate conference.

Note: The White House really needs a win on bipartisan infrastructure, coming between today’s poor Commerce Department numbers on third-quarter GDP growth and next week’s Virginia elections. 

•••

Report: U.S. Intel Failed to Predict Swift Taliban Takeover – Leading U.S. intelligence agencies failed to predict the Taliban’s rapid takeover of Afghanistan following U.S. military withdrawal, according to a review of nearly two dozen documents from four agencies reviewed by The Wall Street Journal. Summaries of classified documents reviewed by the newspaper’s reporters tracked Taliban advances from Spring 2020 to July 2021. 

A key example of the documents dated May 17 of this year, a month after President Biden announced the September 11 withdrawal deadline, was titled; “Government at risk of collapse following U.S. withdrawal.”

Note: This recalls U.S. intelligence failures accusing Saddam Hussein of harboring weapons of mass destruction in Iraq, a couple of years into our nearly 20-year commitment to Afghanistan. It seems we’ve learned nothing and done nothing about the shortcomings of our intelligence agencies in the last 18 or so years.

--Edited by Todd Lassa and Charles Dervarics


_____

Up next; Our left column on whether the Build Back Better plan compromises will leave anyone satisfied by $1.75 trillion worth of social programs. Stephen Macaulay comments from the right. 

Join the conversation and send your comments to editors@thehustings.news

Also in this column …

•David Iwinski on the future of nation building by the U.S. government.

•Our flash debate on the Pandora Papers released by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists. 

•Our quick-take debate on the controversy surrounding Gen. Mark Milley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff regarding his portrayal in the book Peril, by Bob Woodward and Robert Costa. 

_____

By Jim McCraw

Like every other concerned citizen, I’d like to see a Build Back Better reconciliation bill that will stimulate the economy, get control of inflation, fix our sagging, rotting infrastructure and spend some money on generally cleaning up the joint and its atmosphere, without breaking the bank.

Like every other concerned citizen, it worries me that two people, elected to do the will of the people, and who are members of the party in power in the Senate -- not the loyal opposition -- can use the elements of the bill to get on television and, by extension, social media, in order to gather enough money to fund their re-election.  

It also worries me that even a vastly reduced compromise bill has to run to hundreds and hundreds of pages, much of which will eventually involve pork, the food that local politics runs on.

There are also concerns about the current level of ongoing financial commitment involving the aforesaid cleaning up the joint.  I am among those concerned.  Some of us believe that strictly enforcing every one of the federal environmental laws as aggressively as criminal law is better than a $500- to $555-billion chunk of the BBB bill, with severe financial and criminal penalties. Without breaking the bank. 

So here we are, within striking distance of a bill that started out at an otherworldly $3.5 trillion and will probably come in at $1.9 trillion, a monument to the art of negotiation. This is, as always, how it works in America. You listen to me, I listen to you, and then we do what we want.

_____
Please email your comments to editors@thehustings.news

By Todd Lassa

Before coronavirus relief programs by the Trump and Biden administrations made “trillions of dollars” a household term, the $2 trillion “final offer” ceiling that moderate Democrats have placed on the budget reconciliation bill that was due for a self-imposed deadline of the end of October almost seems modest. Happy Halloween. 

When the Biden White House first introduced its $3.5-trillion Build Back Better budget reconciliation plan, progressives led by Sens. Bernie Sanders, I-VT and Elizabeth Warren, D-MA, and Rep. Pramila Jayapal, D-WA, wanted a bigger program, more on the order of $6 trillion. As a 10-year budget program, the progressives’ demands would still be less costly than the federal government’s annual defense budget.

But Republicans and Sens. Joe Manchin III, D-WV, and Krysten Sinema, D-AZ, have the leverage, and object to its potential as a federal debt-buster, and as a recipe for runaway inflation at a time when supply shortages from the pandemic are already pushing skyrocketing prices. 

The seemingly intractable differences between the two major Democratic Party factions has held up a final vote to send the $1.2-trillion infrastructure bill -- $550 billion of it new spending – to President Biden’s desk for signature for two months. Finally, facing falling poll ratings for Biden as congressional Democrats slide toward a very likely loss of power in both chambers from the November 2022 mid-terms, the progressives and moderates appear close to a deal. House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer, D-MD, intends to bring both the infrastructure bill and the reconciliation budget framework to the floor the week of October 25, “if they’re ready,” Politico reports. 

Biden was loose-lipped about the deal-making in his Town Hall on CNN Thursday night. Key compromises …

•Sinema “will not raise a single penny in taxes on the corporate side, and/or wealthy people, period,” Biden said, though the Arizona senator would approve some proposals targeting those groups.

•Two years of free community college is off the table.

•Paid family leave would be funded for up to four weeks, not 12 as proposed in Build Back Better.

•Both Sinema and Manchin oppose extending Medicare to include dental, vision and hearing care. 

•Two major pieces of the bill’s climate change remedies have been removed in order to meet Manchin’s demands; the clean electricity performance program paying utility powerplants to switch to renewable fuels, and a carbon tax, though it appears that programs to mitigate climate control will make up the largest portion of the budget reconciliation bill, at $500- to $555 billion. 

If and when budget reconciliation and the infrastructure plan move on into November, the question is who, if anyone beside President Biden, is satisfied with the result. And speaking of Biden, will these packages do anything for Biden’s standing with the American public? We asked a couple of pundits to tell us what they think.

_____
Please email your comments to editors@thehustings.news

By Stephen Macaulay

It is easy for those who are moderate or progressive Democrats to consider Sens. Joe Manchin, D-WV, and Krysten Sinema, D-AZ, as some sort of stone-age or blood-sucking creatures that we will shortly see on our doorsteps asking for candy.

While it may not be entirely incorrect in terms of characterization -- does Manchin really think that coal has a future? Yes, he has to take care of his constituents -- but wouldn’t a better move be to figure out ways and means to facilitate the further training or education of those people so they can get jobs that aren’t under a black cloud, literally and figuratively?

Here’s the thing that gets somehow overlooked vis-à-vis the Build Back Better bills: Is there not a single Republican who thinks it is his or her job to help advance infrastructure, workers, families, the environment, etc? Where are they? Just what are they doing to earn their paychecks? 

Somehow simply being intransigent isn’t going to fix the roads. Somehow they were all juiced up during the Trump “infrastructure” weeks. What did that deliver? Nothing.

We cannot afford to continue doing that as our global competitors work to advance. Evidently the Grand Old Party is proving that they aren’t in the least bit grand, and they are happy to see the bridges, roads, grid, etc. get old. Want to compete? That won’t cut it.

_____
Please email your comments to editors@thehustings.news

Join the conversation and help us build an alternative social news media platform by emailing your comments to editors@thehustings.news  

Scroll down this column to read ….

•David Amaya on the future of nation building by the U.S. government.

•Our flash debate on the Pandora Papers released by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists. 

•Our flash debate on the controversy surrounding Gen. Mark Milley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff regarding his portrayal in the book Peril, by Bob Woodward and Robert Costa. 

•Pundit-at-large Stephen Macaulay, “The Seriousness of China,” on the growing Cold War with the country.

•The California gubernatorial recall and the future of Trump’s GOP, by Jessica Gottlieb.

•Reader comment on the Biden Administration’s vaccine mandate.

•Macaulay on the vaccine mandate.

____________________________________

Join the conversation and help us build an alternative social news media platform by emailing your comments to editors@thehustings.news   […]

President Biden flies to Rome tomorrow to meet with Pope Francis, ahead of a trip to Glasgow, Scotland, Sunday for next week’s United Nations climate conference.

Email your comments on the latest news and our debates to editors@thehustings.news

Billionaire Income Tax and Half-Trillion for Climate Change Push Negotiations –Senate Finance Committee Chairman Ron Wyden, D-OR, released a “billionaires income tax” proposal targeting about 700 Americans to help pay for the White House’s Build Back Better budget reconciliation bill currently under intense negotiations between moderate and progressive Congressional Democrats, according to multiple sources, including Punchbowl News and NPR’s Morning Edition.

The proposal appears to have widespread support among the two Democratic factions. The budget reconciliation framework has a current target price of $1.75 trillion to $1.9 trillion, but that would be spread out over a number of years, and the approximately $300 billion the billionaires’ tax is expected to raise would cover much of the cost.

On the spending side, Axios reports that the White House is telling lawmakers that the climate change provisions in the reconciliation bill are “largely settled” at $500 billion to $555 billion, making it likely the costliest single expense. This would give President Biden something to talk up when he attends the 2021 United Nations climate conference in Glasgow, Scotland, next week, though he may have to describe it as a proposal, rather than legislation passed by Congress.

How the Billionaire Income Tax Would Work: Wyden’s proposal would tax more than $1 billion in assets, or more than $100 million income over three straight years, including “tradable assets,” known as “marked to market” in which billionaire taxpayers would pay taxes on investment gains or take a deduction on investment losses. This would tax, for example, gains on a stock’s value even if the billionaire investor does not sell the stock to pocket the gain. 

Wyden’s proposal also would impose a minimum tax rate on corporations of 15%, regardless of whether the company posts income or loss in a given year. 

The Finance Committee notes that the Joint Committee on Taxation has not yet scored the proposal, Punchbowl News says.

•••

Lost the Election and >130,000 People: Dr. Deborah Birx, coronavirus response coordinator in the Trump Administration, told the House Coronavirus Crisis Select Subcommittee, “I felt like the White House had gotten somewhat complacent through the campaign season,” in an excerpt released by the subcommittee quoted by The Washington Post. Birx is also quoted: “I believe if we had fully implemented the mask mandates, the reduction in indoor dining, the getting friends and family to understand the risk of gathering in private homes, and we had increased testing, that we probably could have decreased fatalities into the 30%-less to 40%-less range.” Or about 130,000 people.

Trump spokeswoman Liz Harrington responded in a statement: “President Trump led an unprecedented effort to successfully combat the coronavirus, delivering PPE, hospital beds, treatments, and three vaccines in record time. Unfortunately, this approach was not taken up by the current government, and more lives have been lost from covid this year than the entirety of 2020, which the Fake News media places no blame onto Joe Biden.” 

Note: Isn’t the phrase “successfully combat the coronavirus” used by Harrington essentially undercut by reality? Aren’t Joe Biden’s declining poll numbers, regularly quoted by news outlets that are undoubtedly considered “Fake” by Trump and his acolytes, associated with the pandemic? Although there have been some 353,000 deaths this year associated with COVID according to Johns Hopkins University, which exceeds the estimated 352,000 in 2020, doesn’t Harrington realize that were people to have undertaken the recommendations that Birx enumerates, there would have been fewer people infected, which means that there would have been fewer fatalities — in 2020 and 2021?

•••

McConnell Endorses Trump Senate Candidate – In the ongoing gauge of which way the GOP winds are blowing in relationship to Donald J. Trump’s control of the party, this one counts as a “win” for the twice-impeached former president. Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-KY, has endorsed Herschel Walker for next year’s GOP primary to run against incumbent Sen. Raphael Warnock, D-GA, who won his seat in Georgia’s January runoffs to help Democrats take their tie breaker-thin majority.

“Herschel is the only one who can unite the party, defeat Sen. Warnock, and take back the Senate,” McConnell said in a statement issued to Politico. The Senate’s number-two Republican, John Thune of South Dakota, had endorsed Walker on Monday. There has been some concern among Republicans regarding Walker’s personal life, including allegations he drew a gun on his ex-wife.

Walker, the 1982 Heisman Trophy winner as University of Georgia running back, served as co-chair of the President’s Council on Sports, Fitness and Nutrition under the Trump administration. Before playing for several NFL teams, Walker played for the New Jersey Generals, a team of the short-lived U.S. Football League once owned by Trump.

Note: McConnell is still stinging for the GOP’s loss of both Senate seats from Georgia in last January’s special run-offs, after Trump apparently dissuaded Republicans in the state from showing up to the polls with his false “voter fraud” claims, and he clearly sees Walker as providing his best path to retaking the Senate majority leader’s gavel. At a recent rally, Trump threatened another Georgia January: “If we don’t solve the presidential election fraud of 2020 … Republicans will not be voting in ’22 or ’24. It’s the single most important things for Republicans to do.”

•••

Comedian/Satirist Mort Sahl Dies – Joke-writer for John F. Kennedy and personal friend of Ronald Reagan, and cited by the Library of Congress as the “earliest example of modern stand-up comedy on record” for “At Sunset,” recorded in 1955, according to his New York Times obituary, Mort Sahl has died, in Mill Valley, California. He was 94. Sahl’s particular brand of political humor – explaining the “horse shoe” of left-and-right political philosophy, for example -- in the late 1950s and 1960s made him an influence on numerous comedians to come.

--Edited by Todd Lassa, Gary S. Vasilash and Charles Dervarics

____________________________________

TUESDAY, OCTOBER 26, 2021

Executives for TikTok, YouTube and Snapchat testify before the Senate Commerce Committee’s consumer protection panel today on how well their social media platforms protect children online (WaPo).

Moderna has announced it will deliver up to 110 million doses of its COVID-19 vaccine to countries on the African continent, the AP reports. The first 15 million are to be delivered by the end of this year, with another 35 million doses in the first quarter of 2022, and 60 million in the second quarter.

President Biden will announce Tuesday a $100 million initiative to strengthen the U.S. relationship with South East Asia Politico reports, citing the White House. Biden joins a virtual summit today with the 10-member Association of South East Asian Nations, (ASEAN), the first time for a U.S. president since Donald Trump in 2017.

Billionaire Tax Proposed for Budget Reconciliation – A Democratic proposal for a billionaires’ tax to pay for the Build Back Better budget reconciliation bill – now targeted at $1.75-1.9 trillion – is “gaining momentum,” according to The Hill, while Republicans are calling it “too cumbersome” compared with raising taxes on corporations and the wealthy, the Associated Press reports. 

These two interpretations are not mutually exclusive, though they could indicate why Sen. Krysten Sinema, D-AZ, has yet to weigh in on it. Sen. Joe Manchin III, D-WV, seems to approve the provision, according to the AP, while Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-KY, calls it a “hare-brained scheme.”  Some Republicans say the tax scheme, which is meant to raise funds to pay for the budget reconciliation bill without raising the federal debt, could be challenged in court.

It’s based on a 2019 bill by Ron Wyden, D-OR, chairman of the Senate Finance Committee, and would tax the assets of billionaires, many of whom don’t pay much, or anything in taxes on annual income, but earn millions per year from investments. The proposal also would  set a 15% minimum tax rate on corporations, regardless of how they report profits. [GV1] 

According to Roll Call, taxing unrealized capital gains – on stock prices that go up over the tax year but are not cashed in, called “market-to-market” – is gaining momentum given Sinema’s opposition to increased taxes on individuals[GV2]  earning more than $400,000 per year ($450,000 for couples). 

Note: Some Democrats appear ready to call McConnell’s bluff and simply proceed with the tax increases, while Sinema hasn’t publicly weighed in yet – perhaps waiting to see which way the tax winds are blowing.

•••

UN Report Says Global Emissions Will be Up 16% by 2030 – A new United Nations report says global emissions are set to increase as much as 16% by the end of the decade, The Washington Post reports. The new UN report, coming ahead of its climate summit beginning Sunday in Glasgow, Scotland, is based on 192 countries’ commitments to cut greenhouse gas emissions.

In other words, it’s not enough. 

The U.S. and Australia both have committed to becoming carbon neutral by 2050, though President Biden’s target date will be affected by cuts to his climate change proposal in the Build Back Better budget reconciliation bill, and Australia plans to do it, according to the BBC, without shutting down coal or gas production. China has committed to carbon neutrality by 2060.

If countries don’t get more aggressive with plans to cut greenhouse gases, the UN report says, the Earth is expected to be 2.7 degrees Celsius warmer by the end of the century, “far above” the 2C benchmark set in 2015, WaPo says.

•••

Alabama Governor Resists COVID Vax Mandate — “Alabamians are overwhelmingly opposed to these outrageous, Biden mandates, and I stand with them,” Alabama’s Republican Gov. Kay Ivey said in a statement, according to The Washington Post. She has signed an executive order that is meant to counter the federal mandate that requires workers at federal contractors, federal employees, and health workers at facilities Medicare and Medicaid money be vaccinated.

Note: Note the “federal.” The vaccination rate, the Post says, was 44.4% in Alabama, as of late Monday. Aren’t governors supposed to protect their people?

•••

U.S. Aid to Sudan Suspended Following Coup – The Biden administration has suspended $700 million in financial aid to Sudan following yesterday’s military coupe, the AP reports. The aid is on “pause” pending review of developments in Khartoum. The State Department has called for the immediate release of those arrested, including Prime Minister Abdalla Hamdok.

•••

Trump Jr. Sells T-Shirts Mocking Alec Baldwin Shooting – Donald Trump, Jr., is selling t-shirts on his website mocking the fatal shooting of the cinematographer on Alec Baldwin’s Rust movie set, The Hill reports. We won’t repeat the t-shirt’s words, nor the website’s address here with the same warning the NRA often made after several multiple shootings, that now is not the time to politicize a tragedy.

Note: Baldwin had done a masterful job of eviscerating Trump Senior on Saturday Night Live. Presumably Junior is still smarting over that.

--Edited by Todd Lassa and Gary S. Vasilash


MONDAY, OCTOBER 26, 2021

Facebook whistleblower Frances Haugen testifies before the British Parliament today, as new revelations show that the social media platform “meticulously” tracked international harms while ignoring warnings by its own employees about the way poor design decisions affected vulnerable communities around the world (WaPo).

Democrats are looking to wrap up negotiations on the budget reconciliation bill and move its framework along while passing the bipartisan infrastructure bill Wednesday, and finally deliver it to President Biden’s desk before he departs for a trip to Rome on Thursday (The Hill and Punchbowl News.) Details below…

Sudan’s top general has arrested the nation’s prime minister and other top officials in a military coup Monday, the AP reports. Thousands of citizens are reported to have flooded the streets of the capital Khartoum, and its twin city of Omdurman, as Gen. Abdel Fattah Burhan dissolved the government of Prime Minister Abdalla Hamdok.

Delivering Budget Reconciliation on Time? – Medicare expansion and taxes on billionaires are among the key remaining issues Democrats must figure out before moving forward a compromise of President Biden’s Build Back Better budget reconciliation, now expected to come in at $1.75 trillion. 

“In terms of where we are, I have already said we have 90% of the bill agreed to and written,” House of Representatives Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-CA, said on CNN’s State of the Union Sunday. “We just have some of the last decisions to be made.” 

A key swing vote, Sen. Joe Manchin III, D-WV, is amenable to new taxes on billionaires and certain corporations to pay for the pared down social service and climate change programs, the Associated Press reports, after meeting at Biden’s Wilmington, Delaware home with Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-NY. 

Democrats already had missed its latest self-imposed deadline Friday for the budget reconciliation framework and worked through the weekend to get to that 90%. 

Note: Congressional Democrats also are crashing against the end-of-the-month expiration of highway funding (already extended by a month), and Biden’s planned appearance at the United Nations Climate Change Conference in Glasgow, Scotland. Biden will have much less to show at that conference, with his Build Back Better program having been cut in half. But wait, there’s more. Virginia’s gubernatorial election is November 2 – one week from tomorrow (early voting has already begun) – and Democratic candidate Terry McAuliffe needs a Biden legislative victory to give his campaign against Republican candidate Glenn Younkin a bump. Polls say the two Virginia candidates are in a dead heat, but with momentum on the Republican’s side.

Doing the Math:  The numbers behind “trillions of dollars” of White House budget proposals have been thrown around, sometimes willy nilly, in the past half year or so. President Biden had initially proposed $3.5 trillion in spending for 10 years in his Build Back Better budget reconciliation proposal. Sen. Manchin had set an upper limit of $1.5 trillion for the bill, but the latest intel from the AP suggests he will accept up to $1.75 trillion. The bipartisan infrastructure bill – the one the Senate already passed  and is sitting in the House waiting for the budget reconciliation bill, is about $1.2 trillion total, though it’s actually just $550 billion in new spending above programs already funded. 

•••

Members of Congress Involved in January 6 Planning? — Two planners of the January 6 rallies in Washington are alleging “that multiple members of Congress were intimately involved in planning both Trump’s efforts to overturn his election loss and the January 6 events that turned violent,” according to a story in Rolling Stone by Hunter Walker. Walker also writes, “Along with [Marjorie Taylor] Greene, the conspiratorial pro-Trump Republican from Georgia who took office earlier this year, the pair both say the members who participated in these conversations or had top staffers join in included Rep. Paul Gosar, R-AZ, Rep. Lauren Boebert, R-CO, Rep. Mo Brooks, R-AL, Rep. Madison Cawthorn, R-NC, Rep. Andy Biggs, R-AZ, and Rep. Louie Gohmert, R-TX.” 

Also, Walker writes that the sources say Gosar “dangled the possibility of a ‘blanket pardon’ in an unrelated ongoing investigation to plan the protests.”

Note: If this is even partially true, isn’t this a description of a conspiracy to overthrow the Constitution? Party of law and order? 

•••

Charlottesville Civil Trial Begins – Jury selection is set to begin today in the civil trial filed by nine local residents against organizers of the deadly 2017 rally by white supremacists and militia members in Charlottesville, Virginia, per The Washington Post. Defendants include neo-Nazi Jason Kessler, who was a main organizer, and Richard Spencer, a featured speaker. The jury will decide whether the organized rally amounted to a conspiracy to engage in racially motivated violence. The trial is expected to run through November 19.

Note: Recall that Charlottesville’s rally is perhaps most notorious for the comments of then-President Trump, who said there were “very fine people, on both sides,” which he followed up with several dog-whistle comments through the rest of his administration.

•••

Pediatric Vaccinations Coming Next Month – A Food and Drug Administration advisory committee meets Tuesday to discuss a request by Pfizer and BioNTech to allow pediatric COVID-19 vaccinations for five- to 11-year-olds, The Washington Post reports. The advisory committee will inform the FDA’s decision on the request, which then will go on to the Centers for Disease Control & Prevention, which could approve the vaccine for children in that age group, Anthony Fauci, the nation’s top infectious disease expert, said on ABC News’ This Week Sunday.

--Edited by Todd Lassa, Gary S. Vasilash and Nic Woods

____________________________________

•President Biden flies to Rome tomorrow to meet with Pope Francis, ahead of a trip to Glasgow, Scotland, […]

Join the conversation and help us build an alternative social news media platform by emailing your comments to editors@thehustings.news  

Scroll down this column to read…

•David Iwinski on the future of nation building by the U.S. government.

•Our flash debate on the Pandora Papers released by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists. 

•Our quick-take debate on the controversy surrounding Gen. Mark Milley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff regarding his portrayal in the book Peril, by Bob Woodward and Robert Costa. 

•Right-column pundit Bryan Williams, “New Competition May Do Us Some Good,” on the growing Cold War with China.

•Williams again, on the California gubernatorial recall and the future of Trump’s GOP.

•David Iwinski on the Biden administration’s vaccine mandate.

____________________________________

Join the conversation and help us build an alternative social news media platform by emailing your comments to editors@thehustings.news   […]

Scroll down past News & Notes for a debate on the future of nation building by the United States. David Amaya offers his perspective in the left column, and David Iwinski comments from the right, in a preview of an upcoming, October 28 Braver Angels national debate on the issue. 

Join the conversation on this issue, or any of the debates listed below by emailing your comments to editors@thehustings.news

Also in the left column …

•Our flash debate on the Pandora Papers released by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists. 

•Our flash debate on the controversy surrounding Gen. Mark Milley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff regarding his portrayal in the book Peril, by Bob Woodward and Robert Costa. 

•Pundit-at-large Stephen Macaulay, “The Seriousness of China,” on the growing Cold War with the country.

•The California gubernatorial recall and the future of Trump’s GOP, by Jessica Gottlieb.

•Reader comment on the Biden Administration’s vaccine mandate.

•Macaulay on the vaccine mandate.

_____
Please email your comments to editors@thehustings.news

President Biden says he would potentially support Senate Democrats removing the legislative filibuster for a voting rights bill, and “other issues,” in a CNN Town Hall Thursday night. 

”Are you close to a deal?” on the Build Back Better budget reconciliation package, CNN’s Anderson Cooper asked Biden. “I think so,” the president responded.

Sen. Kyrsten Sinema, D-AZ, has reportedly accepted a package of tax changes that would help pay for the budget reconciliation package, NPR’s Morning Edition reports. Moderate and progressive Democrats have negotiated the package to somewhere between $1.75 trillion and $1.9 trillion.

Moderate and Progressive Democrats Still Aren’t There – Despite all the sunshine and bunnies evoked by President Biden and Sen. Krysten Sinema, the two sides aren’t that close to a deal on budget reconciliation. “Democrats are unlikely to strike a framework deal … this week,” The Hill suggests, “as divisions between centrist Democrats and progressives continue to plague negotiations and threaten to derail them entirely.”

In a separate story in The Hill, Sen. Joe Manchin III, D-WV, provided an explanation for the “bullshit” Mother Jones story that said he had threatened to leave the Democratic caucus to become an “American independent.” According to the Capitol Hill newsletter, Manchin told Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-NY, “that if it would help (the Democratic caucus) ‘publicly’ to become an independent who still caucuses with the party” as they negotiate a bill as large as possible in order to appease progressives, he was willing to do so.

Note: Typical storm before the vote, as the herd of Democratic cats keeps trying to gather itself up to vote for the reconciliation bill. Prospects are probably better than it looks – but will either side of the party be satisfied with the outcome?

•••

House Vote is 229-202 to Hold Bannon in Contempt – The full House of Representatives voted 229-202 to hold former Trump advisor Stephen K. Bannon in contempt of Congress for failing to respond to a subpoena to question him for his role in the January 6 Capitol insurrection. Nine Republicans joined House Democrats voting for the contempt charges. Former Vice President Mike Pence’s brother, Rep. Greg Pence, R-IN, did not vote.

Select Committee on January 6 Chairman Bennie Thompson, D-MS, said Bannon “stands alone in his complete defiance of our subpoena,” according to Roll Call. The committee unanimously voted to move Bannon’s contempt charges forward to the full House. The two Republicans on Thompson’s committee, Reps. Liz Cheney of Wyoming, and Adam Kinzinger of Illinois, were among the nine members of their party voting for the charges in the full House.

The others were:

•Peter Meijer and Fred Upton, Michigan.

•John Katko, New York.

•Nancy Mace, South Carolina.

•Anthony Gonzalez, Ohio.

•Brian Fitzpatrick, Pennsylvania.

•Jaime Herrera Butler, Washington.

•••

McCarthy to GOP Consultants: It’s Me or Cheney – A prominent Washington lobbyist close to Rep. Kevin McCarthy, R-CA, is warning political consultants to choose between the House minority leader and January 6 Select Committee member Liz Cheney, R-WY, The New York Times reports. This has prompted “one fund-raising firm to disassociate itself from Ms. Cheney,” according to the report. 

The Morning Group has informed Cheney it can no longer work on her 2022 primary campaign, the NYT says. 

Note: Back in July, Cheney told Fox News she had set two straight record fund-raising quarters in a row after McCarthy ousted her from GOP House leadership, per the conservative-turned-Trumpist magazine, National Review. McCarthy obviously intends to put an end to that, and The Morning Group’s acquiescence to the minority leader will force Cheney to seek help outside the usual channels. This will be a test of how large and serious the post-2016 anti-Trumpist conservative movement really is.

••

Maybe It Wasn’t the Autopilot — Tesla is under investigation by both the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB — which you’re probably more familiar with vis-à-vis plane crashes) and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). 

The issue is whether the company’s so-called “Autopilot” system is the cause of fatalities or crashes, as there seems to be an unfounded understanding that the Tesla vehicles can drive themselves (they can’t). In August, NHTSA opened an investigation of 11 crashes “in which Tesla models of various configurations have encountered first responder scenes and subsequently struck one or more vehicles involved with those scenes.” 

NTSB has been looking at an accident that occurred in Spring, Texas, last April in which there were two fatalities. The NTSB released an update yesterday, according to Automotive News, which indicate that the driver was behind the wheel of the Model S, not in the rear passenger seat, as had been initially claimed by some outlets. The investigation is on-going.

Note: What is interesting about this from a political point of view is that Tesla has been remarkably blasé about the claims that it makes for its “Autopilot” and “Full Self-Driving” (it isn’t) systems. More conventional OEMs have tended to be more responsive to addressing the concerns of federal investigatory agencies. Seems like the same indifference to things like subpoenas by both public servants and private citizens has made its way to corporations, as well.

--Edited by Todd Lassa and Gary S. Vasilash

____________________________________

THURSDAY, OCTOBER 21, 2021

The full House of Representatives votes today on whether to charge former Trump advisor Stephen K. Bannon with contempt of Congress for failing to respond to the January 6 Select Committee investigating his alleged role in the Capitol insurrection. The House is expected to vote in favor of the charges mostly along party lines, plus committee members Reps Liz Cheney, R-WY, and Adam Kinzinger, R-IL.

The FDA has authorized Johnson & Johnson and Moderna COVID-19 vaccine boosters, as well as mixing and matching of the coronavirus vaccines, including Pfizer-BioNTech. In other words, whatever you had as a vaccine, you can take a different booster shot.

Magazine: Manchin Considers Ditching Democratic Party – Sen. Joe Manchin III of West Virginia has told associates he is considering leaving the Democratic Party to become an “American Independent,” and has an exit plan if the $3.5-trillion Build Back Better budget reconciliation isn’t cut in half to $1.75 trillion, according to a scoop by Mother Jones Washington bureau chief David Corn. The revelation in the progressive magazine comes after President Biden appears to have convinced both factions of the party that the ceiling on the budget reconciliation bill will be no higher than $1.9 trillion, in part by reducing the length of key programs within the bill down from 10 years. More important to the coal country senator, the plan would seriously pare down a program to promote clean energy alternatives for powerplants.

Note: The Mother Jones scoop comes just as progressive and moderate Democrats appear to have made progress negotiating the reconciliation bill. Indications are that the White House had agreed to a target price of $1.75 trillion to $1.9 trillion after meeting with progs and moderates separately early this week. Agreeing to the lower price tag will be key to passing the reconciliation budget by the end of October as planned. Manchin can then wait until the end of the year to join independent Sens. Bernie Sanders of Vermont, and Angus King of Maine as officially without a party.

•••

Build Back Faster — President Joe Biden gave a speech yesterday at the Electric City Trolley Museum in Scranton, Pennsylvania, a hometown speech meant to gin up support for the Build Back Better bills that are stalled in the Democratic meeting rooms on Capitol Hill. Biden has been criticized by many in his own party for being insufficiently vocal in support of the legislation. The speech ran for some 8,200 words. Gettysburg Address? About 270. Biden’s speech was about 30 times wordier. 

Note: Biden talked about his parents, grandparents, siblings, neighbors, neighborhoods, riding the trolley, racking up miles on Amtrak, the space race, a school-age nickname, and a variety of other folksy topics. While he did hit on things from job creation to health care to child care, much of it was buried in the vignettes. 

In his peroration Biden said, “I ran for President saying it was time to build the backbone of the nation. And by that, I was very precise: The middle class has been the backbone of this nation.”

Biden buried the lede.

•••

Cloture Fails, as Expected, in Freedom to Vote Act – The Senate on Wednesday rejected Majority Leader Chuck Schumer’s, D-NY, cloture vote on S 2747, the Freedom to Vote Act, along party lines. The bill was Sen. Joe Manchin III’s, D-WV, proposal in September to pare down other bills that seek to counter several state Republican legislatures that are tightening their voting laws in the wake of President Biden’s “landslide” victory over incumbent Donald J. Trump last November. 

Schumer promises to bring other such bills back before the Senate, where he doesn’t have 10 Republicans willing to overcome a filibuster. Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-KY, has kept his 49 fellow caucus members in line by objecting to federal laws that he says would usurp states’ rights on election laws.

Note: It’s the age-old struggle that goes to the question of whether we’re more a democracy or a republic, and entails filibusters, the electoral college, and representation in the Senate itself. Schumer & party are caught in a vicious loop in which filibusters on voting rights bills won’t be overcome without Democrats gaining 10 seats in the Senate, and that won’t happen so long as voting rights legislation continues to fail.

•••

Dead Heat in Virginia Gubernatorial Race – Less than two weeks before Virginia’s election day, with early voting ballots already flooding in, Republican candidate Glenn Youngkin has pulled up to a dead heat in the polls with Democrat Terry McAuliffe. Each has a 46% share of those polled by Monmouth University. McAuliffe, who served as Virginia’s governor from 2014 to 2018, previously had a 2- to 7-point lead in earlier polls.

Note: The gubernatorial election in purple Virginia will be a big indicator of Donald J. Trump’s influence over the GOP, and the electorate in general. While Youngkin, a former CEO of private equity firm The Carlyle Group, has tried to distance himself from the ex-president, Trump endorsed him last weekend, and former Trump attorney Rudy Giuliani put out a bizarre video Wednesday in which he dressed as Abraham Lincoln and criticized McAuliffe for “selling” the Lincoln Bedroom in the White House during the Clinton administration, when he was party chairman – a long-disproven scandal.

•••

Zuckerberg Added to Data Mining Lawsuit – Facebook founder and CEO Mark Zuckerberg has been added to the District of Columbia’s lawsuit over the Cambridge Analytica data-mining scandal, Washington’s attorney general, Karl Racine announced on Twitter. Racine tweeted that his investigation, begun in 2018, has revealed that Zuckerberg was “personally involved in decisions related to Cambridge Analytica and Facebook’s failure to protect user data,” The Verge reports.

Note: Facebook coincidentally has announced it will change its name, though apparently Zuckerberg hasn’t decided, or at least said, what the new moniker will be. It will not be called Truth Social, which is the new social media platform designed as an alternative to big tech like Facebook, announced yesterday by Donald J. Trump.

--Edited by Todd Lassa, Gary S. Vasilash and Charles Dervarics

____________________________________

WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 20, 2021

Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-NY, will hold a cloture vote on the Freedom to Vote Act today. The procedural vote will fail. Details below...

Another Stab at Expanding Voter Rights to Fail – Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-KY, will filibuster S 2747, the Freedom to Vote Act, which Schumer has promised to bring to the floor for a vote. The bill is a pared down version of more expansive bill languishing on Capitol Hill that sought to restore key provisions of the 1965 Voting Rights Act that were negated by the 2013 Supreme Court ruling in Shelby v. Holder. The Freedom to Vote Act was sponsored in September by Sen. Amy Klobuchar, D-MN, and is meant to address new, restrictive voting laws in Georgia, Texas, Iowa, and pending in other states. 

Senate Republicans are not receptive to any federal law that ultimately would give them a disadvantage in future elections, and the only way for this bill to succeed would be a vote ending the legislative filibuster, which Sen. Joe Manchin III, D-WV, opposes. 

Key provisions of S 2747 are:

•Makes election day a federal holiday.

•Expands same-day, and other voter registration rules.

•Expands voter access, including vote-by-mail and early voting.

•Limits removal of voters from the rolls.

•Allows those convicted of a crime to vote, unless serving a felony sentence at the time of the election.

•Establishes certain federal offenses for violating voter laws.

•Requires states to conduct post-election audits for federal elections.

•Addresses redistricting, including “generally” prohibiting mid-decade redistricting.

•••

Yesterday’s Separate White House Talks with Progs, Moderates, Worked – Why not gather progressive and moderate Democrats together in one meeting in order to work out the $3.5-trillion Build Back Better budget reconciliation bill?, we asked yesterday. President Biden met with both groups separately, and it seems to have worked, with NPR reporting “new momentum” toward reaching a deal that would guarantee support from nearly all the House Democrats and absolutely all 50 Senate Democrats. 

Rep. Ro Khanna, D-CA, told NPR’s Morning Edition he feels “closer than ever before” on a deal. The Washington Post reports that Biden has told Democrats that the new target should be a package of between $1.75 trillion and $1.9 trillion. Biden had previously promised the budget reconciliation would be paid for, though funding still apparently must be hashed out.

Note: This compromise will seem to be a victory for moderate Democrats, as Congress cuts the child care tax credit down to a one-year extension, and two years of free community college becomes an expansion of the Pell Grant program. The big winner of course, is Sen. Joe Manchin III, D-WV, who has won some pushback against the climate change programs within the bill. Progressives appear satisfied that some climate change provisions as well as expansion of Medicare benefits will prevail (per WaPo). Paid maternity leave will be pared down to four weeks from the original bill’s 12 weeks.

While it’s a much smaller bill, progressive Democrats appear satisfied that the package provides them some sort of victory – a pretty good win, in fact considering the party’s very narrow majority – as the $1.2-trillion bipartisan infrastructure bill now can finally move through the House and make its way to Biden’s desk to hand him a much-needed victory.

•••

January 6 Committee Forwards Bannon Contempt Charge to House – The House Select Committee investigating the January 6 Capitol insurrection unanimously recommended to charge former Trump advisor and provocateur Stephen K. Bannon be held in contempt for ignoring a subpoena in the case. The full House of Representatives is expected to vote for contempt charges, though Bannon’s failure to appear, and the question of whether he will be compelled to testify, as well as Donald J. Trump’s lawsuit seeking to block the committee from obtaining his White House records, and the Library of Congress from providing them, Roll Call reports.

--Edited by Todd Lassa and Charles Dervarics

____________________________________

TUESDAY, OCTOBER 19, 2021

President Biden will host progressive and moderate Democrats at the White House today in separate meetings in his continuing effort to reach a deal on his Bring Back Better social infrastructure program, the budget reconciliation bill with the $3.5 trillion sticker price. Wouldn’t it be more productive to get both sides in the same meeting?

The Select Committee to Investigate the January 6 Attack on the Capitol is expected to approve contempt charges against Stephen K. Bannon for his failure to respond to a subpoena in a 7:30 EDT session tonight.

Booster shots for COVID-19 do not have to be from the same source as the initial vaccines, the CDC has ruled. Those who have received the single-jab initial vaccine from Johnson & Johnson, which has proved to be less effective than Pfizer or Moderna two-shots, would be better off with a Moderna booster (WaPo).

Trump Sues Committee to Block Release of his White House Records – Former President Trump has filed suit in U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia to block the January 6 Select Committee from obtaining records related to the Capitol insurrection. Trump’s attorneys argue the House of Representatives Select Committee’s request is “almost limitless in scope,” and that most records sought are covered by executive privilege, reports NPR’s Morning Edition.

Note: We’re off to the races, as Trump attempts to block release of the records long as possible. Most analysts and Constitutional scholars agree that the ex-president doesn’t have a legal leg to stand on, though that hasn’t stopped him in more than 4,000 lawsuits during his real estate, reality television and political career. The longer Trump can draw this out, even into next year’s midterm election campaigns, the better for him. Meanwhile, Washington is agog waiting to see whether former Trump adviser Stephen K. Bannon, who was never an official in the administration and nevertheless claims executive privilege, will be carted off to jail.

•••

Colin Powell’s Multiple Myeloma Compromised COVID Vaccine Effectiveness – It shouldn’t be necessary to say this, but former Secretary of State Colin Powell’s death at age 84 Monday from complications of COVID-19 despite having been fully vaccinated was related to his suffering with blood cancer that compromised his immune system. But there are reports that right-wing social media used his death to again question the effectiveness of the vaccines.

“I’ve got multiple myeloma cancer, and I’ve got Parkinson’s disease, but otherwise I’m fine,” Powell told The Washington Post’s Bob Woodward in July, in what was likely his last interview. “Don’t feel sorry for me,” he added.

•••

Alternative to Clean Electricity Program? – Sen. Joe Manchin III’s, D-WV, refusal to accept a $150 billion clean electricity provision in the $3.5 trillion Bring Back Better budget reconciliation bill is sending his congressional colleagues back to the drawing board, as they look for an alternative to appease the coal country senator. 

“I’ve been told it would be prudent to plan alternatives and be very happy if it’s not out,” said Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse, D-RI, described by Roll Call as one of the Senate’s climate hawks. 

Manchin opposes the clean electricity provision, which seeks to fund a shift to solar, wind, nuclear and other renewable energy sources, because “he thinks energy companies are already making the transition,” Roll Call says. 

Note: Punchbowl News says “I told you so,” in a post Tuesday noting that Manchin is sticking with the position he has taken since negotiations begun. That includes a $1.5 trillion cost ceiling with little wiggle-room even though progressive and moderate Democrats reportedly are zeroing in on a final price tag closer to the $2 trillion mark. 

But Manchin’s receptiveness to negotiation was on display yesterday, as he and Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-VT, posed for news cameras together on the Capitol grounds. News & Notes finds it notable that while Roll Call calls Manchin a “moderate Democrat” in its report, Punchbowl News uses the term, “conservative Democrat.” We’d bet the latter tag determines Manchin’s final position, and that the progs will want to develop that clean electricity alternative tout suite.

--Edited by Todd Lassa and Nic Woods

____________________________________

MONDAY, OCTOBER 18, 2021

Former President Bill Clinton has been released and is heading home to New York after spending six days in an Orange County, California, hospital for a non-COVID infection, NPR reports.

Jury selection begins in Georgia today in the trial of Greg McMichael, his son Travis McMichael and neighbor William “Roddie” Bryan for the February 2020 shooting of an unarmed Black jogger, Ahmaud Arbery, in their suburban neighborhood. Jury selection could take weeks, and location for the trial may be moved to a different region of Georgia, WaPo says. 

Two Weeks in Washington – Prepare for two weeks of tortuous negotiations between progressive and moderate Democrats on Capitol Hill as the two sides haggle over how to cut President Biden’s Build Back Better program, the $3.5-trillion budget reconciliation bill, to about $2 trillion, The Hill previews. 

On Saturday The New York Times reported that Sen. Joe Manchin III, D-WV, told the White House he “strongly opposes” a $150-billion provision in the bill to quickly replace coal- and gas-fired powerplants in the U.S. with wind, solar and nuclear energy. Biden travels to Glasgow in two weeks for a United Nations summit on climate change, and Manchin’s demands to remove the $150 billion provision will make it difficult to convince the rest of the world that the U.S. is serious about the problem, the NYT notes.

Another point of contention to be hashed out in two weeks is a provision in the bill, also championed by progressives, to reduce the cost of prescription drugs. It faces opposition by Sens. Bob Menendez, D-NJ, and Krysten Sinema, D-AZ, according to The Wall Street Journal.

Note: While conventional wisdom on Capitol Hill says that Congress loves deadlines and will work all this out in two weeks, these points of contention appear to be more of a power struggle between the two sides of the Democratic Party than simply differences in political philosophy. The $1.2-trillion infrastructure bill has been under threat since House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-CA, agreed to connect its passage to the budget reconciliation bill, and now the U.S.’s already poor image on climate change seems likely to suffer, too, as Donald J. Trump’s GOP watches Biden’s presidency fail under the weight of his own party.

•••

Buttigieg Says Supply Chain Won’t Be Fixed Soon — “A lot of the challenges that we have been experiencing this year will continue into next year,” Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg said on CNN’s State of the Union, regarding the global supply chain. As for what the Administration can — or can’t — do, he said on NBC News’ Meet the Press, “Nobody wants the federal government to own or operate the stores, the warehouses, the trucks or the ships or the ports. Our role is to try to make sure we’re supporting those businesses and those workers who do.”

Note: Those last comments would qualify Buttigieg for hurrahs from the traditional Republican party, were such a thing still in existence.

One of the things that somehow seems to get overlooked when there are discussions of the broken supply chain is the fact that there has been a global pandemic since March 2020. Had all the countries in the world gotten after it when it first started spreading rather than, in some cases we are familiar with, thought it would go away on its own through some magical thinking, it would not have the magnitude that it has — and will continue to have. Sick workers can’t make microchips.

In addition to which, it is worth recognizing that this is a global problem, and not something that is the consequence of Joe Biden’s presidency.

•••

China’s Economy Stalls – China’s economy grew 4.9% over the last year, The Wall Street Journal reports, and while this may seem positive by the standards of the world’s largest economy (yes, the U.S. is still number-one), for number-two, it’s not that good. The Chinese economy is up this year only in comparison with the nadir from the effects of the coronavirus pandemic, and even then it pales next to China’s annual increases during the last decade that were typically in the 8-10% range. 

Compounding the poor economic outlook are a.) reports of electricity outages across China due to energy shortages and b.) the expected collapse of Evergrande, the country’s most indebted real estate developer. Companies like Evergrande have overbuilt real estate in China for decades, resulting in “ghost” buildings and even “ghost” cities according to numerous reports.

Note: China’s dominance of the global economy may not be quite the threat we thought, though Evergrande’s fate will affect the U.S. economy as well. More troubling is how China’s economy could continue to affect the supply chain for computer chips and electronic devices, and how it might affect the urgency of China’s urgency in retaking control of Taiwan.

•••

Obituary: Former Secretary of State Colin Powell – Colin Powell, the four-star general who became the first Black chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, under President George H.W. Bush, and the first Black secretary of state under President George W. Bush, died Monday from complications of COVID-19. Powell was once considered a potential candidate for president, though he declined to run. As Bush 43’s secretary of state, Powell launched war against Iraq to prevent Saddam Hussein’s government there from using “weapons of mass destruction” (WMDs), that were later revealed to not exist. Powell, 84, was awarded the Congressional Medal of Freedom twice. He was fully vaccinated, his family said in a Facebook post. (From reports by Politicoand NPR’s Morning Edition.)

--Edited by Todd Lassa and Gary S. Vasilash

_____
Please email your comments to editors@thehustings.news

Scroll down past News & Notes for a debate on the future of nation building by the United States. David Amaya offers his perspective in the left column, and David Iwinski comments from the right, in a preview of an upcoming, October 28 Braver Angels national debate on the issue. 

Join the conversation on this issue, or any of the debates listed below by emailing your comments to editors@thehustings.news

Also in the right column …

•Our flash debate on the Pandora Papers released by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists. 

•Our quick-take debate on the controversy surrounding Gen. Mark Milley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff regarding his portrayal in the book Peril, by Bob Woodward and Robert Costa. 

•Right-column pundit Bryan Williams, “New Competition May Do Us Some Good,” on the growing Cold War with China.

•Williams again, on the California gubernatorial recall and the future of Trump’s GOP.

•David Iwinski on the Biden administration’s vaccine mandate.

_____
Please email your comments to editors@thehustings.news

By David Amaya

It is a strange task to elucidate how the world’s most robust and influential military belongs to a liberal democracy that is not afraid to use its force to prop up democratic political regimes in foreign nations (i.e., nation build). American Exceptionalism would summarize this Wilsonian mission as benevolence. Germany and Japan are two shining examples of successful American nation building – both have successful economies and democracies. Since those two efforts (which have roots in World War II), public opinion seems to gravitate towards exiling nation building and instead align itself with ex-President Trump’s isolationist agenda – “America First.”

One bridge that connects the American political divide is the overwhelmingly negative response to America’s nation building attempt in Afghanistan. An ability to nation- build that once gave us credibility and respect (Germany’s and Japan’s democracies) has now become our folly and walk of shame as we exit Afghanistan. 

The question of whether America should continue or cease nation building efforts is suspicious. Respondents must realize their answers are a pseudo-prescient anecdote that doesn’t consider the volatility and unpredictability of our (that is, the world’s) human nature. No one should be against humanitarian intervention; the dignity of man is worth preserving across the globe and history. 

A separate question we hesitate to answer is whether nation building can succeed without the world's most powerful military placing bets it can successfully prop up an authentic democratic regime. Another: can a nation’s sovereignty and self-determination be persuaded through other means to believe in democracy for themselves? Suppose the United States ever finds itself nation-building without the use or threat of its military prowess. In that case, we will find ourselves in a new era of foreign policy that can bring honor to democracy and American Exceptionalism yet again. Today, I believe everyone wants our troops home so we can all have this conversation together. 

_____
Please email your comments to editors@thehustings.news

By Todd Lassa

Search “nation building” and you’ll turn up an article reposted all over the Internet, including newly minted Nobel Peace Prize Laureate Maria Ressa’s website, Rappler, as well as a number of left-leaning outlets, that cite an interview former National Security Advisor John Bolton gave shortly before the fall late last summer of Afghanistan to the Taliban, in which he blames the U.S. failure there after 20 years on the “change in our mission from anti-terrorism to nation building.”

Bolton’s comments might surprise supporters of both ex-President Trump, who employed Bolton as his national security advisor from April 2018 to September 2019, and supporters of President Biden, who has sided with his predecessor on a couple of key policy issues, including the need to completely extract the U.S. military from Afghanistan. In this case, both Trump and Biden should be at odds with Bolton, who is known more for his push while working for the George W. Bush administration to invade Iraq after the September 11, 2001 attacks in order to remove Saddam Hussein despite no evidence he had anything to do with the terrorism, or had a secret stash of nuclear warheads. 

That brings us back to the present day. On Sunday, October 10, Iraqis held an election for its parliament, but turnout according to myriad news reports was low, Politico reports, with some voters simply vandalizing their own ballots in protest. Like Afghanistan, Iraq’s democratically elected government has been rife with corruption and incompetency, even with six such parliaments following the 2003 eradication of Hussein.

While our experiences in Iraq and Afghanistan are vastly different in the details – especially the post-U.S. fate of the Afghanis -- they raise the same key question: Was it a mistake to try and remake both these nations in our own image? One prevalent post-mortem on Afghanistan is that we fought not one 20-year war, but instead, 20 one-year wars. How did Iraq get to six national elections in 18 years? 

Conversely, advocates of American nation building counter that the U.S. has the responsibility to spread freedom and democracy among countries that suppress their citizens, or are suppressed by bigger, more powerful countries. In the much-repeated op-ed cited at the beginning of this column, author Waldon Bello, a senior analyst for Focus on the Global South and international adjunct professor of sociology at State University of New York at Binghamton, writes that American nation building did not begin with Vietnam, but instead with the Philippines in the late 19th century, and worked in rare occasions, such as the rebuilding of Japan after its World War II defeat. He concludes, however, that nation building does not work. 

On October 28, Braver Angels will hold a national debate, Resolved: America Should Stop Nation Building. 

In the left and the right columns, you’ll find but two perspectives in preview of some of the points of view to be expressed. Go to braverangels.org for details on how to participate in the debate.

_____
Please email your comments to editors@thehustings.news

By David Iwinski

While many claim the United States has never successfully engaged in the process of nation building and, thus, should swear off this process forever, it turns out that's not exactly the case. We don't have to go all the way back to the beginning of the Republic to find at least two superb examples of how the influence, funding and process of American engagement led directly to significant changes in political orientation and global cooperative participation.

At the end of World War II, Germany was not only in financial shambles but with the shattering of the dominant Nazi party and their ideology, they faced a crisis of identity and national meaning. One of their allies, Japan, was in even more catastrophic shape. Clobbered by two atomic bombs designed to rapidly end the war and stop both the deaths of American soldiers and Japanese civilians, they also faced the utter shock of coming to the reality that perhaps the Emperor was not directly connected to God and could not be considered omnipotent. They also had a long history of hyper-aggressive militant behavior that manifested itself in their outward relations with the world.

The Marshall Plan, also known as the European Recovery Program, was a U.S. program providing aid to Western Europe following the devastation of World War II. American money helped rebuild the cities, factories, railroads and other modes of transportation while simultaneously engaging in the reconstruction of governmental entities and policies with a focus on cooperative behavior and economic development. In short order, Germany became one of the leading manufacturers in Europe – it is the continent’s leader today, providing German citizens with not only a wealthy lifestyle but also a safe one promoting cooperation and peaceful engagement with its neighbors.

In Asia, General MacArthur went into Japan and after writing them a new Constitution, essentially restructured and rebuilt the nation from the ground up. He instituted such radical reforms as universal suffrage and other changes designed to not only modernize the landscape of Japan but also the thinking of the people. Japan embraced these changes to such an extent that within a couple decades it became a successful manufacturing colossus and is now one of the world’s leading economies.

What's interesting are the preconditions for these extraordinarily successful nation-building efforts. The first is that the aggressive and dysfunctional existing governments had to offer complete surrender and capitulation, not only being rejected by outside nations but the good citizens of their own country as well. The second is that the American efforts were direct and structural, going to the heart of what needed to be done and doing it fast.

As I see it, the major problem with nation building in the modern era is that dysfunctional governments we have attempted to reform may have been militarily conquered or humbled, but they have never surrendered nor acknowledged defeat. They have remained in a state of semi-power and, as a result, the people in these nations have not had the ability to fully embrace a new regime or a new way of thinking.  Peace was maintained by virtue of American troops, guns and money but there was no fundamental change of heart from people living in these nations on the ground.

Modern nation building, as it seems to exist today, tries (and fails) because we strive to be "kinder and gentler" and think of wholesale social change can be accomplished via soft persuasion and sweet slogans. We desire to change hearts and minds while leaving in place those negative elements that created the problem in the first place. We think if we can just be a good example and plant a few crops that the people who were brutally dominated under the old regime will have the intestinal fortitude to fight them off once we walk out the door. With that in mind, I would say that our post-World War II nation building efforts have had this fundamental flaw, making them a terrible waste of blood and money.

If we desire to truly help the beleaguered people of a nation run by tyrannical despots who shower brutality upon their own people, the rules of engagement must allow us to go in hard and fast to root them out and completely dominate the terrain of both the land and the political landscape so that they have nowhere to hide and either face, as the Japanese did in 1945 the decision to capitulate or be completely destroyed. Under those circumstances, we would have a chance of a successful effort in the participative democracy and the establishment of successful republics.

Is this vision likely to occur? Honestly, I think not. When we try to run wars based on calling back home for legal advice before we decide which terrorist we can shoot, we are so far away from helping the people we claim to be trying to save that we might simply be better off staying home. 

_____
Please email your comments to editors@thehustings.news